Question 1
2 marksGive two reasons why Cleomenes demanded that Cleisthenes and many other Athenians should be expelled from Athens.
Model answer
Isagoras, his guest-friend, asked him to, because he was losing to Cleisthenes. The excuse was that the Alcmaeonids were under a curse, because they had been blamed for killing Cylon's supporters after they had taken refuge as suppliants.
Explanation
Herodotus (5.70-5.71) explains that Cleomenes acted on Isagoras' instructions and used the old 'curse' of the Alcmaeonids, from the Cylon affair, as the pretext. Each different reason earns a mark.
Mark scheme
-
2 marks
Any two of: Isagoras asked him to / he acted on Isagoras' instructions; Isagoras was his guest-friend (since the siege of the Peisistratids); the Alcmaeonids and their supporters were said to be under a curse (for killing the supporters of Cylon, who had taken refuge as suppliants); to weaken Cleisthenes and his supporters so that Isagoras could hold power; (Herodotus reports) it was said that Cleomenes was having an affair with Isagoras' wife
1 mark for each different correct answer, max 2. Allow recognisable spellings. Credit each different reason once. Accept 'to drive out the pollution / the accursed'. Credit the rumour about Isagoras' wife only if it is presented as a reason Herodotus reports.