'Alexander's murder of Cleitus shows that he had become a tyrant.'
How far do you agree with this view?
You must use and analyse the ancient sources you have studied as well as supporting your answer with your own knowledge.
Model answer
The murder of Cleitus shows that Alexander could behave like a tyrant, but I do not think it proves that he had become one.
The case for the statement is strong. Alexander killed a senior Companion, the man who, as Arrian says, had saved his life at the Granicus, without any trial and in a moment of rage. Cleitus' complaints point to a king who was becoming a Persian despot: Arrian says he had long been angry at Alexander's imitation of 'foreign kings', and Plutarch has him protest that Macedonians were beaten with 'Median rods' and had to beg Persians for an audience with their own king. Alexander was surrounded by flatterers, and when his guards did not obey him, Arrian says, he complained that he had only the name of king. Afterwards Anaxarchus told him that whatever a king did was just, a tyrant's principle. Callisthenes, in the speech Arrian gives him, warned that Macedonian kings ruled 'not by force but by law'. The killing also fits a pattern that included the deaths of Philotas and Parmenio and, later, of Callisthenes.
However, the sources also present the killing as a drunken disaster rather than an act of tyranny. Plutarch says it happened 'not of set purpose' but through misfortune, anger and wine. Cleitus provoked Alexander repeatedly and returned after being led out. Arrian, following Aristobulus, says the fault was entirely Cleitus', and Arrian himself criticises Cleitus' insolence. Most strikingly, Alexander was immediately overcome with remorse: both writers say he lay grieving and refusing food, and Plutarch says his guards had to stop him killing himself. Arrian praises him for confessing his crime 'as a man and not a god', and says elsewhere that he was the only ancient king who repented of his errors.
These judgements need care. Aristobulus and Ptolemy were Alexander's friends, and Aristobulus' claim that Cleitus was entirely to blame looks like a defence. Arrian's own purpose was to show Alexander as a king who repented, and both Arrian and Plutarch wrote under Roman emperors, when the contrast between a good king and a tyrant was a familiar theme, so they may shape the story to make that point. Plutarch, however, includes details damaging to Alexander, such as the apple thrown at Cleitus, so he is not simply defending him.
Overall, the murder shows the dangers of Alexander's growing power, his flatterers and his temper, but his remorse and the fact that his friends could restrain him suggest he had not yet become a tyrant. It was a warning sign rather than proof, and the later deaths of Callisthenes and others show that the warning was justified.
Explanation
Level 5 answers use both Arrian and Plutarch to weigh evidence of tyranny (no trial, Persian customs, flatterers, the wider pattern) against evidence of a drunken accident followed by remorse, and analyse the sources' purposes (Aristobulus' defence, Arrian's theme of repentance, the Roman context). Narrative alone is capped at 8.