'Darius' expansion of the empire was driven mainly by a desire for wealth.'
To what extent do you agree with this view?
Spelling, punctuation and grammar and the use of specialist terminology will be assessed in this answer
Model answer
Darius greatly expanded the Persian Empire, into India, Thrace, the Hellespont region and the Aegean islands, and he also attacked the Scythians. Wealth was certainly one motive, but I will argue that his expansion was driven by a mixture of motives, and that glory and security mattered at least as much.
The case for wealth is strongest in India. After Scylax's voyage down the Indus, Darius conquered Hindush, and Herodotus says the Indians paid 360 talents of gold dust a year, the largest tribute of all. Indian ivory was used in the palace at Susa. In Thrace, Megabazus warned Darius that Histiaeus' new city at Myrcinus had timber for ships and silver mines, which shows that the Persians knew the value of the region. Control of the Hellespont, the Bosporus and islands such as Samos, Lemnos and Imbros gave Persia control of rich trade routes, including the grain route from the Black Sea. Darius' tribute system, which earned him the nickname 'shopkeeper', shows that revenue mattered to him.
However, wealth cannot explain the Scythian campaign. Herodotus says Darius wanted revenge because the Scythians had once invaded Media and ruled Asia for twenty-eight years. Idanthyrsus told Darius that the Scythians had no towns or farmland, so there was little to gain. Herodotus also tells the story of Atossa urging Darius to make a great conquest so that the Persians would see they had a real man as king. This suggests that glory and the need to prove himself were important.
Royal ideology also played a part. Darius' inscriptions present him as 'king of lands of every kind of people', ruling by the favour of Ahuramazda, and the throne-bearers on his tomb show the many peoples under his rule. A larger empire proved the god's favour and the king's greatness.
Security and opportunity mattered too. Conquering Thrace and the cities on the Bosporus protected the routes between Europe and Asia. Samos was taken partly because Syloson asked Darius to restore him as a reward for the gift of a cloak, so personal ties gave Darius an opportunity. This case also shows the limits of the wealth explanation: Darius promised Syloson to restore the island 'without killing or enslaving anyone', which suggests that gratitude and loyalty mattered more to him than plunder. Darius was also curious about the edges of the world: Herodotus says he explored most of Asia.
In conclusion, wealth was important, especially in India and the Aegean, but it was not the main driving force of Darius' expansion. The desire for glory as a universal king, revenge and security explain the Scythian campaign and much of the expansion in Europe, so I largely disagree with the statement.
Explanation
Level 5 answers examine several areas of expansion and weigh wealth (India's gold, trade routes, silver mines) against revenge, glory, royal ideology, security and opportunity, reaching a clear judgement. Answers that only discuss India or only Scythia are limited, and one-sided answers are capped at 12. Terms such as tribute, expansion and frontier, used accurately, support the SPaG mark.