'Alexander's victories over the Persians were due more to Persian mistakes than to his own skill.'
How far do you agree with this view?
You must use and analyse the ancient sources you have studied as well as supporting your answer with your own knowledge.
Model answer
Persian mistakes certainly helped Alexander, but I would argue that his own skill was more important, because he created and exploited their mistakes.
There is good evidence of Persian errors. Arrian says that at the Granicus the satraps rejected Memnon's advice to destroy the crops and avoid battle, and then lined the river bank with cavalry, leaving their Greek mercenary infantry behind where they could not help. At Gaugamela, Darius kept his army standing in arms all night for fear of a night attack, so that, as Arrian says, fear 'thoroughly cowed their spirits'. During the battle the Persian cavalry rode out to surround Alexander's wing and opened a gap in their own line, and Darius was 'the first to turn and flee'. Plutarch also describes Darius abandoning his chariot.
However, we must be careful with these sources. Arrian's account comes mainly from Ptolemy and Aristobulus, Macedonian officers who admired Alexander and liked to show the Persians as frightened. The claim that Darius fled first may be propaganda; the Babylonian diary, written at the time by Babylonian scholars, says instead that his troops deserted him. The Alexander Mosaic, which shows Darius turning in his chariot as Alexander charges, is a later copy, probably of a Greek painting made to celebrate Alexander, so it is not independent evidence of cowardice.
Moreover, many 'mistakes' were caused by Alexander. The Persians stood in arms all night because Alexander had chosen not to attack at night, and the gap opened because his oblique advance to the right forced Darius to send cavalry round his wing. Arrian describes Alexander's preparation in detail: he reconnoitred the ground, placed a second line to deal with encirclement and posted light troops to defeat the scythed chariots. At the Persian Gates, after a failed frontal attack, he led a night march round the Persian position while Craterus attacked from the front. Arrian had been a general himself, and this military detail is convincing.
The Persians were also dangerous enemies. At the Granicus the first Macedonians to cross 'suffered badly', and at Gaugamela the armoured Scythian and Bactrian cavalry pressed Alexander's right hard while Persian horsemen broke through to the baggage. Victory needed discipline and quick decisions, such as Alexander turning back from the pursuit of Darius to help Parmenio, which Arrian says led to the fiercest cavalry fight of the day, in which about sixty Companions were killed. An army that won only because of enemy mistakes would not have needed to fight so hard.
Overall, Persian mistakes made Alexander's victories easier, and the sources may exaggerate Persian fear, but it was Alexander's planning, tactics and leadership that turned those mistakes into decisive victories.