Passage C
Aristotle describes the powers of the Council of Five Hundred.
'In earlier times the council had full power to fine, to imprison and to put to death. But when it had handed over a man called Lysimachus to the executioner, and he was already sitting waiting to die, Eumelides of Alopece rescued him, saying that no citizen ought to be put to death without the decision of a law court. A trial was held in a court and Lysimachus was acquitted... and the people took away from the council the power to put anyone to death, imprison him or fine him... The council examines most of the officials, especially those who handle money, but its judgement is not final: there is an appeal to the law court... So in all these matters the council does not have the final say. But it considers in advance everything that comes before the people, and the people may not vote on anything that the council has not discussed first and the prytaneis have not put on the agenda.'
Aristotle, The Athenian Constitution 45 (adapted)
Using details from Passage C, how accurate do you think Aristotle's account of the powers of the council is?
Model answer
Aristotle's account is accurate on the main principle but less certain on details. He wrote in the 4th century BC, so he describes the council of his own time, and the passage mixes this with a story from 'earlier times'. The Lysimachus story has no date and reads like an anecdote with a moral, 'no citizen ought to be put to death without the decision of a law court', so we cannot use it to say when the council lost these powers. However, his central claim, that the people 'may not vote on anything that the council has not discussed first', is supported by 5th-century inscriptions, which begin 'it was decided by the council and the people'; in the Brea decree a citizen with a further proposal has to be brought before the council first. The appeals to 'the law court' also fit the growth of the courts after Ephialtes. Overall it is a reliable description of how the council prepared business, but not precise evidence for its powers in Pericles' time.
Explanation
Strong answers separate the reliable general description (backed by 5th-century inscriptions) from the undated Lysimachus anecdote, and remember that Aristotle describes the 4th-century system. Avoid the misconception that Aristotle took part in the democracy: he was a metic in Athens and could not.