'The phalanx, not the cavalry, was the key to Alexander's success in battle.'
How far do you agree with this view?
You must use and analyse the ancient sources you have studied as well as supporting your answer with your own knowledge.
Model answer
The phalanx was essential to Alexander's success, but I do not think it was more important than the cavalry: the key was how the two worked together.
There is a strong case for the phalanx. At Gaugamela Alexander had about 40,000 infantry and only 7,000 cavalry, according to Arrian, so the phalanx was the bulk of his army. Its role was to hold the enemy's centre: Arrian describes it 'packed close and bristling with long pikes', and he says it was the attack of both the cavalry and the phalanx that made Darius flee. Plutarch adds that after the cavalry charged, 'the phalanx rolled on after them like a flood'. Alexander also gave the phalanx a second line, which turned round to rescue the baggage when Persian cavalry broke through. At the Granicus, once the Persian cavalry had fled, it was the phalanx that destroyed the Greek mercenaries.
However, the sources also show that the cavalry usually decided the battle. Arrian describes the Granicus as a cavalry battle in which the Persians gave way first where Alexander charged. At Gaugamela the decisive moment came when Alexander formed a wedge of the Companion cavalry and charged through the gap towards Darius. Cavalry also won the struggles on the flanks: Menidas and Aretes fought off the outflanking Persian horsemen, and the Thessalians held the left wing under Parmenio. Arrian says the fiercest fighting of the day was a cavalry battle, in which sixty Companions died. Plutarch, too, says that at Gaugamela 'the cavalry charged at full speed upon the enemy' before the phalanx followed, so in his account the cavalry led the way.
The sources may exaggerate the cavalry's role. Arrian's main source, Ptolemy, was a cavalry officer close to Alexander, and Plutarch writes biography, so both focus on Alexander, who fought on horseback. The visual sources do the same: the Alexander sarcophagus and the Alexander Mosaic show Alexander as a rider, because that was how a hero was portrayed, and neither shows the phalanx in action. Arrian, however, was a Roman general who recorded the infantry dispositions carefully, so his account is more balanced than it first appears.
Overall, neither arm was the key on its own, and the sources, for all their bias, show this clearly. The phalanx fixed the enemy and protected the army, while the cavalry, led by Alexander, delivered the decisive blow; light troops and Alexander's leadership tied them together. If one must be chosen, the cavalry was the arm that turned holding actions into victories, so I disagree with the statement, while accepting that without the phalanx the cavalry's charge could never have succeeded.