'Alexander's relationship with Philip was based on rivalry rather than respect.'
How far do you agree with this view?
You must use and analyse the ancient sources you have studied as well as supporting your answer with your own knowledge.
Model answer
There was certainly rivalry between Alexander and Philip, but I think it grew out of respect rather than replacing it.
The evidence for rivalry is strong. Plutarch says Philip's marriages caused 'many quarrels', and at Cleopatra's wedding Philip drew his sword on his son after Alexander threw a cup at Attalus; Alexander then mocked his father and left for Illyria. Plutarch also tells of the Pixodarus affair, in which Alexander went behind Philip's back. Later, during the campaign, Alexander seemed to push his father aside: according to Arrian, flatterers at Maracanda belittled Philip's deeds and pleased Alexander, and when Cleitus praised Philip, Alexander killed him. Plutarch has Cleitus accuse him of disowning Philip to call himself the son of Ammon.
However, these sources need care. Plutarch, writing around AD 100, was a biographer who chose dramatic anecdotes to show character, and the direct speech at the wedding is probably polished. The Cleitus story happened when both men were drunk, and Arrian, using Ptolemy and Aristobulus, admits that the flatterers caused the trouble, so it shows Alexander's growing pride rather than a lifelong hatred of his father. Some ancient writers even suspected Alexander of a part in Philip's murder in 336 BC, but Diodorus, writing in the 1st century BC, explains the killing by Pausanias' private grievance against Attalus and Philip, and does not blame Alexander at all. The suspicion probably tells us more about later rumours than about the relationship.
The evidence for respect is also strong. Plutarch says Philip wept for joy when Alexander tamed Bucephalas, tried to persuade rather than command him, chose Aristotle as his teacher, and made him regent at sixteen. Philip was even glad to hear Alexander called king. After their quarrel they were reconciled through Demaratus. Alexander in turn carried out the Persian war that Diodorus shows Philip had begun, and after the Granicus his dedication at Athens began 'Alexander, son of Philip', according to Arrian. Arrian quotes the inscription itself, so this is strong evidence, unlike Plutarch's anecdotes. Even Callisthenes, in the speech Arrian gives him, reminds Alexander that he is 'the son of Philip', whose family ruled the Macedonians by law; whether or not the speech is accurate, it shows that Philip's name still carried weight in the army.
Overall, the relationship was based on respect: each recognised the other's ability. The rivalry was real, but it arose because Alexander wanted to equal and surpass a father he admired, and it was made worse by Philip's marriage, which threatened Alexander's succession. The sources that stress conflict are mostly later anecdotes, while the actions of both men show respect.