'Olympias was responsible for the murder of Philip.'
How far do you agree with this view?
You must use and analyse the ancient sources you have studied as well as supporting your answer with your own knowledge.
Model answer
Olympias certainly had a motive to want Philip dead, but I do not think the sources prove that she was responsible for his murder.
The case against her is based mainly on motive and character. Plutarch describes the quarrel at Philip's wedding to Cleopatra, when Attalus prayed for a 'legitimate heir', insulting Alexander and, by implication, Olympias. Plutarch calls her 'jealous and resentful' and says she 'urged Alexander on'; mother and son then left the court. Outside the set chapters, Plutarch says most of the blame for the murder fell on Olympias for encouraging Pausanias, and Justin tells how she honoured the assassin's body. Her later actions show she could be ruthless: after Philip's death she killed Cleopatra Eurydice and her baby, and Plutarch reports that years later she put many men to death and scattered the ashes of Iolas.
However, this evidence is weak. Plutarch wrote about 400 years later as a moral biographer and introduces these claims as what was said, not as proven facts. Much of the tradition about Olympias may come from her enemy Cassander, who had her killed in 316 BC. Justin is a late and sensational summary. None of these writers gives evidence of contact between Olympias and Pausanias.
Diodorus, our fullest account, gives a different explanation. He says Pausanias had been shamefully treated by Attalus and was angry that Philip refused to punish him, giving him gifts instead; Pausanias then wanted revenge 'on the one who had failed to avenge him'. Diodorus wrote in the 1st century BC and likes to show fate at work through omens, but his explanation is detailed and logical, and Aristotle, who lived at the time and knew the Macedonian court, also says Pausanias acted because of an outrage. Diodorus does not mention Olympias at all.
Other people also had motives. Alexander's succession was threatened by Philip's new marriage, and some suspected him too. Alexander blamed the Persians, who were about to be invaded, and he executed the Lyncestian brothers. Because Pausanias was killed immediately by the bodyguards, his backers, if any, could never be identified, and each suspect's guilt became a matter of rumour. It is also worth noting that Diodorus describes Philip sending his guards away so that he could appear protected by the goodwill of the Greeks, which gave Pausanias his chance: the murder needed an opportunity more than a powerful backer.
In conclusion, Pausanias had his own powerful motive, supported by the best evidence. Olympias may have welcomed, or even encouraged, his anger, but the claim that she was responsible depends on late, hostile sources and on her reputation rather than on proof, so I largely disagree with the statement.
Explanation
Strong answers weigh the evidence for Olympias' guilt (motive, Plutarch's report, her later ruthlessness) against Diodorus' and Aristotle's personal explanation and other suspects, evaluating the sources (Plutarch's rumours, Cassander's hostility, Diodorus' approach). Answers that list suspects without evaluating sources are capped at 8.