'Between 479 and 465 BC the Persians lost control of the Aegean because of the strength of Athens rather than the weakness of Persia.'
To what extent do you agree with this view?
Spelling, punctuation and grammar and the use of specialist terminology will be assessed in this answer
Model answer
The Persians lost control of the Aegean between 479 and 465 BC because Athenian strength met Persian weakness. Athens provided the force that drove the Persians out, but it could do so because Persia had been badly weakened and had lost the loyalty of its Greek subjects.
The case for Athenian strength is strong. Thanks to Themistocles' naval programme, Athens had the largest Greek fleet and experienced crews. In 478/477 BC it became the leader of the Delian League, which organised ships and money from many states to continue the war against Persia. Under Cimon the League captured Eion on the Strymon, won over Greek cities in Caria and Lycia and forced Phaselis to join. At the Eurymedon Cimon showed real skill: Plutarch says he widened his ships' decks to carry more hoplites, attacked before the Phoenician reinforcements arrived, defeated the fleet and then the army on the same day, and finally destroyed the reinforcements at Hydrus.
However, Persian weakness was just as important. By 479 BC Persia had already suffered heavy defeats at Salamis, Plataea and Mycale. Its Greek subjects were disloyal: at Mycale the Ionians turned against the Persians, and afterwards they joined the Delian League willingly. The Persian fleet, which depended on Phoenician ships and crews, lacked confidence; at both Mycale and the Eurymedon it avoided a sea battle. The King himself seems to have lost interest in the west. After 479 BC Xerxes stayed at Sardis and then returned to Persia, and Greek sources describe him absorbed in building and in family quarrels, such as the affair that led to the death of his brother Masistes. He was finally murdered in a palace plot in 465 BC.
It should also be remembered that Athens was not alone. In 478 BC the Spartan Pausanias led the fleet that won over Cyprus and captured Byzantium, and the League included many allied ships. Athens' leadership depended on the willingness of the Ionians to follow it, which was itself a result of their hostility to Persian rule.
On the other hand, Persia was not weak everywhere. It could still gather a large fleet and army in Pamphylia in the 460s, which suggests that, without Cimon's decisive attack, the Persians might have regained the initiative. The kings may also have chosen to accept the loss of a distant frontier rather than spend more on it, which would be a decision rather than a sign of weakness.
Overall, I partly agree. Athenian sea power and leadership were the direct cause of the Persian loss of the Aegean, as the Eurymedon shows. But Athens was able to act because Persia had been weakened by defeat, had lost the loyalty of the Greeks of Asia and had a king more concerned with his court than with the west.
Explanation
Strong essays weigh specific evidence for Athenian strength (the fleet, the Delian League, Cimon's campaigns) against Persian weaknesses (earlier defeats, Ionian disloyalty, a cautious fleet, Xerxes' withdrawal and murder) and show how the two were connected. Answers that only describe the Delian League do not address the Persian side.