'Persian culture under Darius was mostly borrowed from the peoples he conquered.'
To what extent do you agree with this view?
Spelling, punctuation and grammar and the use of specialist terminology will be assessed in this answer
Model answer
Persian culture under Darius certainly borrowed a great deal from the peoples of the empire. However, I will argue that the Persians combined these borrowings into something new and distinctively their own, so the statement is only partly true.
There is plenty of evidence of borrowing. Darius' Susa charter says the stonecutters were Ionians and Lydians, the goldsmiths Medes and Egyptians and the brick-makers Babylonians. Persian art reflects this: the glazed brick friezes of Susa use a Babylonian technique, the carved processions and guardian figures follow Assyrian traditions of palace decoration, the doorways of Darius' palace at Persepolis are topped with Egyptian-style cornices, and the statue of Darius found at Susa was made in Egypt in Egyptian style. Government used older writing systems: cuneiform, and the Elamite and Aramaic languages, as the Persepolis tablets show. Herodotus says the Persians adopted foreign customs more readily than any other people, such as Median dress and the Egyptian corselet. Even in religion, the Persepolis tablets record offerings to Elamite and Babylonian gods.
On the other hand, borrowing was only the starting point. At Persepolis these elements were combined into a new style. The Apadana reliefs show long, calm processions of peoples bringing gifts, with no scenes of slaughter like those in Assyrian palaces: a peaceful image of empire that was new. Even borrowed techniques served Persian purposes: the glazed brick archers of Susa, made with a Babylonian method, show royal guards in Persian court robes, and the Apadana delegations are arranged to honour the Persian king. Darius also introduced Old Persian cuneiform for royal inscriptions; in the Behistun inscription he says he made the text 'in Aryan', in the Persians' own language.
Persian religion was also distinctive. Darius' inscriptions place Ahuramazda, 'the greatest of the gods', at the centre, and describe the world as a struggle between truth and 'the Lie'. Herodotus says the Persians worshipped in the open, without temples or statues, and needed a Magus at every sacrifice. Darius' tomb shows him before a fire altar.
Other Persian traditions were not borrowed at all. Herodotus says Persian boys were taught three things, riding, archery and telling the truth. Royal gardens, or 'paradises', and rock-cut cross-shaped tombs were Persian features. Above all, the idea of one king ruling many peoples by the favour of Ahuramazda shaped everything: the borrowing itself was deliberate, showing that all the peoples of the empire served the king.
In conclusion, Persian culture under Darius drew heavily on the skills and traditions of conquered peoples, especially in art and writing. But these were combined into a distinctive Persian culture with its own religion, values and image of empire. I therefore disagree that it was mostly borrowed.
Explanation
Level 5 answers give specific examples of borrowing (craftsmen at Susa, Assyrian and Babylonian art, Elamite records) and of distinctively Persian features (Old Persian script, Ahuramazda and the Lie, the peaceful style of Persepolis, Persian education), and reach a judgement about the difference between borrowing and combining. One-sided answers are capped at 12. Terms such as cuneiform, relief and glazed brick, used accurately, support the SPaG mark.