'Pasargadae was built to show off Cyrus' power rather than to unite the peoples of his empire.'
To what extent do you agree with this view?
Spelling, punctuation and grammar and the use of specialist terminology will be assessed in this answer
Model answer
Pasargadae was certainly built to display Cyrus' power, but the way it was built also presented an empire made up of many peoples. I will argue that these two aims went together, but that showing royal power was the main one.
The evidence for display is strong. Strabo says Cyrus built Pasargadae as a memorial of his victory over Astyages, on the site of the battle, so from the start it celebrated conquest. The site was designed to impress: a monumental gatehouse with huge stone bulls at its doorways, an audience hall with tall stone columns, and a royal garden with stone water channels showing the king's control over nature. The inscriptions, in the name of 'Cyrus the king, an Achaemenid', stressed the dynasty. Cyrus' great stone tomb presented him as the founder of the empire. Pasargadae also stood in Persis, the Persians' homeland, where Strabo says the treasure and royal tombs were kept, so it was a centre of Persian royal power rather than a meeting place for all peoples.
On the other hand, the buildings brought together many traditions. The stone platform and tomb were built with Lydian and Ionian methods, probably by craftsmen from Sardis after 547/546 BC. The gatehouse bulls and the reliefs of a bull-man and a fish-cloaked figure came from Assyrian and Babylonian art, and the four-winged figure wears an Elamite robe and an Egyptian crown. The inscriptions were written in Old Persian, Elamite and Babylonian. This fits Cyrus' policy elsewhere: he presented himself as Marduk's chosen king in Babylon and allowed the Jews to rebuild their Temple. Pasargadae may therefore have sent the message that all peoples belonged to one empire under one king.
However, we should be careful. The mix of styles may simply reflect which craftsmen were available after the conquest of Lydia, not a deliberate plan, and the trilingual inscriptions may have been added later by Darius. A visitor to Pasargadae was more likely to be struck by the size and wealth of the buildings than by their mixture of styles.
In any case, showing power and uniting peoples were not really opposites. By using the skills and symbols of conquered peoples, Cyrus showed that they now served him. The winged figure, combining the styles of several peoples, was itself an image of power over many lands.
In conclusion, Pasargadae was mainly built to show off Cyrus' power and to celebrate his victory, as Strabo suggests. But because that power rested on many conquered peoples, it was shown in a style that brought their cultures together. So I largely agree with the statement, although the 'uniting' message was part of how that power was displayed.
Explanation
Level 5 answers use specific features of Pasargadae (Strabo's victory memorial, the gatehouse bulls, the winged figure, the Lydian masonry, the trilingual inscriptions) as evidence for both purposes and reach a clear judgement. A general description of the site without addressing the 'rather than' in the statement is capped at 12. Terms such as relief, paradise and trilingual, used accurately, support the SPaG mark.