'Darius' organisation of the empire was his greatest achievement.'
To what extent do you agree with this view?
Spelling, punctuation and grammar and the use of specialist terminology will be assessed in this answer
Model answer
Darius achieved a great deal: he won back a collapsing empire, built Persepolis and Susa, expanded his territory and reorganised the government. I will argue that his organisation of the empire was his greatest achievement because it lasted longest and made everything else possible.
The case for the statement is strong. Darius divided the empire into twenty satrapies, each under a satrap, and fixed the tribute every province paid, measured by standard talents of silver or gold. Herodotus says the yearly total came to over 14,000 talents. He introduced the gold daric and silver siglos and standard weights. To control his satraps he used royal secretaries, garrison commanders who answered to the king and inspectors known as the 'King's Eye'. The Royal Road, with its 111 staging posts and relays of royal messengers, carried orders and reports across the empire. This system lasted, with changes, until Alexander's conquest almost two hundred years later, which is a remarkable achievement.
However, there are strong rival claims. The pacification of 522-521 BC was essential: Darius fought nineteen battles in a single year and defeated nine rebel kings, including two in Babylon and one in Media. Without this, there would have been no empire to organise, so it could be seen as his most important achievement.
His building projects were also impressive and lasting. Persepolis, with its Apadana showing the peoples of the empire bringing gifts, and the palace at Susa, built with materials and craftsmen from across the empire, expressed the unity of the empire under its king. The canal from the Nile to the Red Sea linked Egypt with Persia. Darius also expanded the empire into India, Thrace and the Aegean.
The organisation had weaknesses. The Persians called Darius a 'shopkeeper' because of his tribute system, and heavy demands may have contributed to the Ionian Revolt. Some satraps, such as Oroetes, acted almost independently. Darius also suffered failures, such as the Scythian campaign and the defeat at Marathon.
Nevertheless, the pacification was an emergency response and the buildings were symbols, while the organisation of the empire shaped how millions of people were governed for generations. It provided the tribute that paid for Persepolis and the armies that expanded the empire. The craftsmen from many lands who built the palace at Susa, listed in Darius' foundation charter, and the workers whose food rations are recorded on the Persepolis tablets were paid through this system, and the Royal Road carried armies and supplies as well as messages. In this sense the organisation of the empire was the achievement on which all the others depended.
In conclusion, the pacification was the most urgent of Darius' achievements, but his organisation of the empire was the greatest, because it turned Cyrus' conquests into a lasting state.
Explanation
Level 5 answers compare Darius' organisation (satrapies, tribute, coinage, the Royal Road) with other achievements such as the pacification, the building programme or expansion, recognise weaknesses, and reach a substantiated judgement. Describing the reforms alone is capped at 12. Terms such as satrapy, tribute, administration and pacification support the SPaG mark.