'The Jews benefited more from Cyrus' rule than any other people.'
To what extent do you agree with this view?
Spelling, punctuation and grammar and the use of specialist terminology will be assessed in this answer
Model answer
The Jews gained a great deal from Cyrus' rule, and their writers praised him more than any other foreign king. However, other peoples, especially the Babylonians and the Persians themselves, also benefited, and the benefits to the Jews were not as complete as the Jewish sources suggest.
The case for the statement is strong. Since Nebuchadnezzar's deportations of 597 and 587/586 BC, many Jews had lived in exile in Babylonia. According to the Book of Ezra, in his first year Cyrus issued a decree allowing them to return to Jerusalem and to rebuild the Temple, with help from their neighbours in silver, gold and animals. A second version, found at Ecbatana, says the costs should come from the royal treasury. Cyrus also returned the Temple vessels that Nebuchadnezzar had taken; Ezra counts over five thousand. No previous ruler had done this, and Isaiah calls Cyrus God's 'shepherd' and his 'anointed', a title given to no other foreigner. The Jews regained their homeland and their place of worship.
On the other hand, the Babylonians also gained. The Cyrus Cylinder claims Cyrus entered Babylon peacefully, ended the forced labour imposed by Nabonidus and protected the temples, and the Nabonidus Chronicle says the gods Nabonidus had brought into Babylon were returned to their cities. The Cylinder also says Cyrus returned the gods of many other cities to their shrines and allowed their peoples to go home. This suggests the Jews benefited from a general policy rather than special favour.
The Persians benefited most of all. Under Cyrus they changed from being subjects of the Medes to rulers of the largest empire the world had yet seen, gaining the treasures of Ecbatana, Sardis and Babylon. Some conquered peoples, such as the Medes, also kept power, since nobles like Harpagus and Mazares commanded Cyrus' armies.
The benefits to the Jews were also limited. The return was voluntary, and many families who had settled in Babylonia stayed there. Those who went back found Jerusalem in ruins and faced hostility from their neighbours, so the gains took a generation to arrive, whereas the Babylonian elite kept their temples, offices and wealth from the first day of Cyrus' rule. Local opposition stopped the rebuilding, and the Temple was not finished until 515 BC under Darius. Cyrus had practical reasons too: a grateful Judah lay on the route to Egypt. Our evidence comes mostly from Jewish writers, who saw him as God's agent and may have exaggerated his generosity.
In conclusion, the Jews benefited more in religious and emotional terms than any other conquered people, because they regained their homeland and Temple. But measured by wealth and power, the Persians benefited most, so I only partly agree with the statement.
Explanation
Level 5 answers compare the Jews with other peoples using precise detail (the decree, the vessels, Isaiah; the Babylonian temples and gods; the Persians' new empire) and decide what 'benefited more' means. Answers that only describe the return of the Jews are capped at 12. Terms such as exile, decree and tolerance, spelled and used accurately, support the SPaG mark.