'Between 493 and 490 BC the Persians relied more on diplomacy than on force in their dealings with the Greeks.'
To what extent do you agree with this view?
Spelling, punctuation and grammar and the use of specialist terminology will be assessed in this answer
Model answer
Between 493 and 490 BC the Persians used diplomacy a great deal, but it always depended on the threat of force, and when Greeks resisted, force was used without hesitation.
There is much evidence of diplomacy. After the Ionian Revolt, Artaphernes made the Ionian cities settle their disputes by arbitration and fixed their tribute at about the old level, a settlement that Herodotus says lasted to his own day. In 492 BC Mardonius went further, removing the tyrants and setting up democracies, a policy designed to win loyalty rather than to impose it. In 491 BC Darius sent heralds throughout Greece to demand earth and water; all the islanders and many mainland states, including Aegina, gave them. Thasos even pulled down its walls and handed over its ships simply because Darius ordered it. In 490 BC Datis showed great respect at Delos, telling the Delians to return home and burning 300 talents of frankincense on the altar. The Persians also used Greeks: Hippias guided them to Marathon, and traitors opened the gates of Eretria.
However, the threat of force lay behind all of this. The heralds came while Darius was ordering warships and horse transports, and the islands gave earth and water because they knew what would happen if they refused. After 494 BC the Persians had burned the Ionian cities and 'netted' the islands. Mardonius' expedition of 492 BC was a full-scale invasion with an army and fleet, and the Brygi were conquered by force.
When diplomacy failed, force was used. In 490 BC Naxos, which had resisted in 499 BC, was burned and its people enslaved. Carystus refused to give hostages or join the expedition, so the Persians besieged it and ravaged its land until it gave in. Eretria was besieged for six days, its temples were burned and its people enslaved, as Darius had ordered. Datis was sent with orders to enslave Athens too, and only the defeat at Marathon prevented this.
Even the respect shown at Delos had a purpose. By honouring the birthplace of Apollo and Artemis, Datis showed that the Persians respected the gods of those who submitted, while the burning of temples at Naxos and Eretria showed the price of resistance. The two methods were parts of a single policy, designed to persuade as many Greeks as possible to give earth and water without a fight.
Overall, I partly agree. Persia preferred to win the Greeks over by diplomacy, and that worked with most of the islands and many mainland cities. But Persian diplomacy worked because Greeks feared Persian force, and towards the cities that had helped the Ionian Revolt or refused to submit - Naxos, Eretria, Carystus and Athens - force, not diplomacy, was the main method.
Explanation
Strong essays cover the whole period and both methods, with specific examples on each side (democracies, heralds, Delos against Naxos, Carystus, Eretria and Marathon), and recognise how diplomacy and force worked together. Answers that only describe Marathon are too narrow.