Explain the differences between the treatment of Miltiades and the treatment of Aristides by the Athenian democracy.
Model answer
The Athenian democracy treated both Miltiades and Aristides with suspicion, but the way it dealt with them, and the results, were very different.
The most important difference was in the method. Miltiades was put on trial in a law court. Nepos says that after he failed to take Paros he was accused of treason, of having been bribed by the Persian king to give up the siege. Aristides, by contrast, was removed by ostracism, a vote of the whole people that needed no accusation of a crime; Plutarch stresses that ostracism was not a punishment for wrongdoing.
The punishments were also different. Miltiades was fined fifty talents, the cost of the fleet; since he could not pay, Nepos says, he was imprisoned and died there. Aristides was simply exiled for ten years and kept his property.
The outcomes differed too. Miltiades died in disgrace soon after the trial. Aristides served less than three years of his exile: when Xerxes invaded, the Athenians recalled all the ostracised men, and Aristides returned to serve the city again.
The treatment of the two men also differed in the honours they had received. Nepos complains that Miltiades, who had saved Greece at Marathon, was given only the honour of being painted first among the ten generals in the picture of the battle in the Stoa Poikile, whereas Aristides, a general at Marathon, was made archon the following year.
There was, however, an important similarity in the underlying reason. Nepos says the real reason for Miltiades' condemnation was the fear that he had become too powerful, after his long rule in the Chersonese. Plutarch says the Athenians called their envy of Aristides 'fear of tyranny'. In both cases a rival helped turn the people against them, Themistocles in the case of Aristides.
Overall, both men suffered because the democracy feared powerful individuals, but Miltiades was treated as a criminal while Aristides was removed by a milder political procedure that allowed him to return.
Explanation
A 'differences' question needs both men: an answer describing only Miltiades or only Aristides is capped at 4 marks. The best answers compare in several areas (method, charge, punishment, outcome) and note the shared underlying reason.