Question 1
2 marksGive two reasons why, according to Thucydides, Harmodios and Aristogeiton plotted against the Peisistratids.
Model answer
Hipparchus had tried to win Harmodios' love and been rejected, and Aristogeiton, Harmodios' lover, feared Hipparchus would take him by force. Then Hipparchus insulted Harmodios by inviting his sister to carry a basket in a procession and sending her away as unworthy.
Explanation
Thucydides (6.54, 6.56) insists that the plot began with a love affair and a personal insult, not with a plan to free Athens. Each different reason earns a mark; the insult to the sister and the rejected advances are separate reasons.
Mark scheme
-
2 marks
Any two of: Hipparchus tried to win Harmodios' love and was rejected / it began as a love affair; Aristogeiton, Harmodios' lover, was angry and afraid that Hipparchus would use his power to take Harmodios by force; Hipparchus insulted Harmodios by inviting his sister to carry a basket in a procession and then turning her away as unworthy; they wanted to overthrow the tyranny (hoping others would join them and win their freedom)
1 mark for each different correct answer, max 2. Allow recognisable spellings. Credit each different reason once. Credit the Athenian Constitution's version (Thessalus, not Hipparchus, made the advances and insulted the sister) if the reason is the same. Credit 'to overthrow the tyranny' or 'to free Athens from the tyrants' as one reason (Thucydides 6.54 says Aristogeiton then plotted to overthrow the tyranny). Credit any other valid answer from Thucydides.