'Thucydides' admiration for Pericles makes him an unreliable source for Periclean Athens.'
How far do you agree with this view?
You must use and analyse the ancient sources you have studied as well as supporting your answer with your own knowledge.
Model answer
Thucydides clearly admired Pericles, and this affects his judgements, but I do not think it makes him an unreliable source overall. His facts are usually trustworthy, even where his opinions are favourable.
There is evidence that his admiration shapes his account. His final verdict on Pericles praises him for leading Athens 'with moderation', for his 'foresight' and for being incorruptible, and blames his successors, whose rivalry handed affairs to the 'whims of the people'. This was written after Pericles' death and probably after Athens' defeat in 404 BC, so hindsight may have made Pericles look wiser than he was. The Funeral Oration presents an idealised Athens in Thucydides' own words. He also says little about the criticisms that other sources record: Aristophanes blames Pericles' anger and the Megarian decree for the war, and Plutarch says Pericles alone was held responsible and reports the attacks on his friends Pheidias and Aspasia. Thucydides, by contrast, makes Spartan fear of Athenian power the 'truest cause', which takes attention away from Pericles' role.
On the other hand, Thucydides does not hide Pericles' difficulties. He records that the Athenians, suffering from war and plague, turned against Pericles, sent envoys to Sparta and fined him, and he describes the plague's horrors frankly. He also includes the Megarian decree and the Spartan demand that it be withdrawn. Many of his facts are confirmed by other evidence: the tribute and building records inscribed at the time broadly support his picture of Athens' wealth, and Plutarch confirms that the gold on Athena's statue was removable. As a contemporary and a former general, he knew events at first hand, and he explains his careful method of checking reports. He also had no need to flatter Pericles: he wrote long after Pericles' death, in exile, with nothing to gain from praising him, which suggests his admiration was a genuine judgement rather than bias for profit.
The other sources have weaknesses too. Aristophanes was writing comedy to make his audience laugh and to argue for peace, so his blame of Pericles is exaggerated. Plutarch wrote more than five hundred years later and relied partly on comic poets and hostile writers, although he admits how hard it is to find the truth and often follows Thucydides himself. Thucydides' admiration, therefore, should be weighed against their hostility.
Overall, I disagree with the statement to a large extent. Thucydides' admiration makes his judgements of Pericles too favourable and leads him to say little about some criticisms, so his opinions must be read with care. But his factual account of politics and war is generally reliable and is confirmed by other sources, which makes him the most valuable source we have for Periclean Athens, even if he is not a complete one.
Explanation
High-level answers distinguish Thucydides' judgements of Pericles (affected by admiration and hindsight) from his factual reporting (generally confirmed), test both against Plutarch, Aristophanes and inscriptions, and evaluate those sources too. Answers that simply call Thucydides 'biased' or 'reliable' without analysis stay at Level 2.