'Xerxes dealt with the revolts in Egypt and Babylon too harshly.'
To what extent do you agree with this view?
Spelling, punctuation and grammar and the use of specialist terminology will be assessed in this answer
Model answer
Xerxes certainly dealt firmly with the revolts in Egypt and Babylon, but the evidence that he was 'too harsh' is weaker than it first appears, and his firmness was effective.
The case for excessive harshness begins with Egypt. Herodotus says that when Xerxes reconquered the province in about 485-484 BC, he reduced it to a much harsher slavery than under Darius. He placed his brother Achaemenes in charge, keeping power in family hands, and there is little evidence that he supported Egyptian temples or presented himself as a traditional pharaoh, as Darius had done.
Babylon seems to have suffered more. After the revolts of 484 BC under Bel-shimanni and Shamash-eriba, the family archives of many leading Babylonians come to an end, which suggests that the rebel elite were removed. Herodotus says Xerxes took a twelve-cubit golden statue from the temple of Bel and killed the priest who tried to stop him - something Darius had not dared to do. The daiva inscription, in which Xerxes boasts of destroying a sanctuary of false gods, may refer to one of these provinces. Such treatment may have caused lasting resentment: Egypt revolted again under Inaros soon after Xerxes' death, and Achaemenes was killed.
On the other hand, the revolts were serious threats. Egypt and Babylonia were two of the richest provinces, paying large amounts of tribute, and a revolt left unpunished might encourage others. Every Persian king dealt firmly with rebels: Darius' Behistun inscription describes rebel leaders being captured and executed in 522-521 BC. From the Persian point of view, rebels had broken their loyalty to the King and to the order of Ahuramazda, so punishing them was a royal duty rather than cruelty, and Xerxes' own inscriptions present it in exactly this way. Xerxes' response worked. The Babylonian revolts were ended within months, and both provinces remained under control for the rest of his reign.
The evidence for extreme harshness is also doubtful. Later Greek writers such as Arrian and Strabo claimed that Xerxes destroyed the temple of Bel, but Babylonian documents show it still working afterwards. Herodotus admits he did not see the golden statue himself and calls it a statue 'of a man', so it may not have been the god's cult image. Most of our evidence comes from Greeks, who saw Xerxes as an arrogant tyrant because he had invaded their land, and the daiva inscription does not even name the place it describes.
Overall, I disagree with the statement. Xerxes punished the rebels, especially the Babylonian elite, more severely than Darius had, but there is little reliable evidence of wholesale destruction, and his firm response restored order quickly in two vital provinces. He was harsh, but not obviously too harsh by the standards of Persian kingship.
Explanation
Strong essays use specific evidence for both provinces (Herodotus on Egypt, the statue of Bel, the Babylonian archives, the daiva inscription) and weigh it against the seriousness of the revolts and the problems with Greek sources. Answers that confuse these revolts with Darius' Babylonian revolts of 522-521 BC lose credit.