'The Corinthians opposed tyranny only because of their own experience of Cypselus and Periander.'
How far do you agree with this view?
You must use and analyse the ancient sources you have studied as well as supporting your answer with your own knowledge.
Model answer
The Corinthian speech in Herodotus is built around the history of Corinth's own tyrants, so experience was clearly a major reason for their opposition. But principle and political self-interest were also involved, so I disagree that it was the only reason.
The case for experience is strong. Socles tells the Spartans that if they had experience of tyranny, as the Corinthians had, they would judge it better. Most of his speech is the story of Corinth's tyrants: Cypselus, who exiled many Corinthians, seized the property of many and killed far more; and Periander, who after Thrasybulus' lesson in the cornfield killed the outstanding citizens and stripped all the women of Corinth of their clothes for his dead wife Melissa. The speech ends: 'Such is tyranny, Spartans'. The Corinthians clearly drew their arguments from what they remembered, and these were vivid, personal memories of exile and death rather than abstract theory.
However, the speech also argues from principle. It begins by calling tyranny the most unjust and bloodthirsty thing among men and the opposite of 'equal government', and it ends by calling on the gods of Greece not to set up tyrannies. Socles also accuses the Spartans of hypocrisy for imposing on others what they would never accept at home, a political complaint about how Sparta treated its allies. When he finished, the other allies agreed with him, so opposition to tyranny was not just a Corinthian memory.
Self-interest may have mattered too. A free and strong Athens was a useful balance to Sparta inside the alliance, and Corinth had already shown its independence in 506 BC by abandoning Cleomenes' invasion because it was 'not acting justly'. Corinth's record was also not purely principled: it had helped Sparta attack Polycrates of Samos, but Herodotus says this was revenge for the Samians' rescue of the Corcyraean boys, not opposition to tyranny.
The source needs careful evaluation. The speech was composed by Herodotus about seventy years later, and the stories of the smiling baby, the chest and Melissa's ghost read like Corinthian folk tales told to condemn the tyrants. Herodotus also wrote when Corinth had become Athens' enemy, and Hippias' prophecy that Corinth would regret saving Athens looks back from that time. Herodotus admired freedom, as his comment on isegoria shows, which may colour his presentation of Corinth's arguments. We cannot know exactly what Socles said, only what Herodotus thought a Corinthian would say.
Overall, Corinth's experience of Cypselus and Periander gave its opposition its force, but the speech's appeal to justice and the gods, the support of the other allies and Corinth's political interests show that experience was not the only reason.
Explanation
High marks need a judgement on the balance of reasons (experience, principle, self-interest), supported by the speech and by Corinth's actions in 506 BC and against Polycrates, with Herodotus' composition of the speech evaluated.