Passage B
Persian troops under Otanes have arrived to make Syloson ruler of Samos. Maeandrius has agreed to leave, but his brother Charilaus urges him to attack the Persians.
'Maeandrius accepted Charilaus' plan. In my opinion he did this not because he was foolish enough to think his own forces could defeat the King's, but because he resented Syloson getting the city back without effort and undamaged. He wanted to anger the Persians and make Samos as weak as possible before handing it over, knowing that if the Persians suffered harm they would turn bitterly against the Samians; and he knew he had a safe way off the island whenever he wanted, since he had had a secret tunnel dug from the acropolis to the sea. So Maeandrius sailed away from Samos, while Charilaus armed all the mercenaries, opened the gates and sent them out against the Persians... Then Otanes, the Persian general, seeing the heavy losses the Persians had suffered, deliberately forgot the orders Darius had given him, not to kill or enslave any Samian, and told his army to kill everyone they caught, man or boy alike.'
Herodotus, Histories 3.146-3.147.1 (adapted)
Using details from Passage B, how accurate do you think Herodotus' account of the Persian takeover of Samos is?
Model answer
Herodotus' account is probably accurate in outline but unreliable in its details. The main events - Maeandrius' escape, Charilaus' attack with the mercenaries and the Persians' violent response - are likely to be true, since a massacre on this scale would have been remembered on Samos, where Herodotus had informants. However, he admits that Maeandrius' motive is only his own guess ('In my opinion'), and the secret tunnel to the sea is the kind of dramatic detail that is impossible to check. The claim that Darius had ordered that no Samian be harmed puts the blame on Otanes alone and presents the King well, which may reflect a tradition friendly to Darius or to Syloson. Finally, 'everyone they caught, man or boy' is surely exaggerated: Samos sent sixty ships to Lade only about twenty-five years later. So the passage reliably shows that the Persian takeover was violent, but the motives and numbers are Herodotus' interpretation.