'Cambyses' conquest of Egypt was a complete success.'
To what extent do you agree with this view?
Spelling, punctuation and grammar and the use of specialist terminology will be assessed in this answer
Model answer
The conquest of Egypt was Cambyses' greatest achievement and, in military terms, a clear success. However, the campaigns that followed failed, and the conquest brought problems for Egypt, for Cambyses and for the empire, so it was not a complete success.
The conquest itself was impressive. In 525 BC Cambyses crossed the desert with the help of the Arab king, defeated the Egyptians in a hard-fought battle at Pelusium and took Memphis after a siege. The Libyans, Cyrene and Barca submitted without fighting. Egypt, the richest kingdom left outside the empire, became a Persian province, and it stayed in the empire for more than a century; under Darius, Herodotus says, it paid 700 talents in tribute. With the Phoenician and Cypriot fleets now serving Persia, the empire also became a naval power.
Cambyses was also successful in winning over the Egyptian elite. The inscription of Udjahorresnet shows him taking the royal name Mesuti-Ra, using Egyptian officials, restoring the temple of Neith at Sais and making offerings there. A stela from the Serapeum shows an Apis bull buried with honour in his sixth year. In this sense he made Persian rule acceptable. His treatment of Psammenitus followed the same approach: the defeated king was kept at court unharmed and, according to Herodotus, might have been made governor of Egypt if he had not plotted a revolt.
On the other hand, Cambyses' further plans failed badly. According to Herodotus, the army sent against the Ammonians vanished in a sandstorm, the expedition against the Ethiopians ran out of food and had to turn back, and the attack on Carthage was abandoned because the Phoenicians refused to sail against their own colony. Cambyses had hoped to make Egypt a base for wider conquests, and that hope was not fulfilled.
The conquest also caused lasting hostility. Psammenitus plotted a revolt, and Egypt rebelled again at the end of Darius' reign. Egyptian priests seem to have resented Cambyses, perhaps because, as a later Egyptian text records, he cut temple revenues, and their stories gave him the reputation of a mad tyrant that we read in Herodotus. Even Udjahorresnet mentions 'very great troubles' in the country.
Finally, the conquest had serious consequences for the empire. Cambyses stayed in Egypt for about three years, and in his absence a Magus seized the throne in Persia, claiming to be his brother Smerdis. Cambyses died on his way home in 522 BC, and the empire fell into crisis until Darius restored order.
In conclusion, the conquest of Egypt was a lasting military and political success, since Egypt remained Persian for over a century. But the failed expeditions, the hostility of the priests and the crisis caused by Cambyses' long absence mean that it was not a complete success.
Explanation
Level 5 answers separate the conquest itself (Pelusium, Memphis, the submission of Libya and Cyrene, Egyptian collaboration) from the failures that followed (the three expeditions, revolts, priestly hostility, the crisis of 522 BC) and decide what 'complete' means. One-sided answers are capped at 12. Terms such as province, tribute and expedition, used accurately, support the SPaG mark.