Passage C
In Xenophon's dialogue The Estate Manager, a wealthy Athenian called Ischomachus tells Socrates how he taught his young wife her duties.
''Will I have to do these things too?' asked my wife. 'Certainly,' I said. 'Your duty will be to stay indoors and to send out those servants whose work is outside, and to supervise those who are to work indoors. You must receive what is brought into the house, give out what has to be spent, and look after what is to be stored, taking care that what has been put aside for a year is not spent in a month. When wool is brought to you, you must see that clothes are made for those who need them, and that the dried grain is kept fit to eat. One of your duties, though, may perhaps seem rather thankless: you will have to see that any servant who falls ill is looked after.' 'Oh no,' said my wife, 'that will be a great pleasure, if those who are well cared for are going to be grateful and more loyal than before.''
Xenophon, The Estate Manager 7.35-7.37 (adapted)
Using details from Passage C, how accurate do you think Xenophon's account of an Athenian wife's duties is?
Model answer
Xenophon's account is probably accurate for the ideal of a wealthy household, but not for all Athenian women. He wrote in the 4th century BC about a conversation set in the late 5th century, so he is fairly close to the period. The duties he describes - supervising servants, managing stores, making sure 'clothes are made' from wool and keeping 'the dried grain' - fit other evidence of women's work, and 'stay indoors' matches the ideal in Pericles' Funeral Oration that a woman should be least talked of. However, this is a philosophical dialogue about good management, so it presents an ideal, and the wife's eager reply ('that will be a great pleasure') is written by a man to show a model wife. Ischomachus is rich, with many servants, so the picture does not fit poor women, who often worked outside the home. Overall, it is accurate for the ideal of wealthy families, but limited as evidence for most women.