Passage B
After the battle of Marathon some Athenians claimed that the Alcmaeonid family had signalled to the Persians by holding up a shield. Herodotus gives his view.
'I find it astonishing, and I do not accept the story, that the Alcmaeonids would ever have held up a shield as a signal to the Persians by agreement, wanting the Athenians to be under the barbarians and Hippias. For they clearly hated tyrants as much as Callias son of Phaenippus did, or even more... I do not accept the charge that they showed the shield, since they were in exile from the tyrants for the whole time, and it was by their scheme that the Peisistratids gave up the tyranny. In my judgement it was they who freed Athens, much more than Harmodios and Aristogeiton. For those two, by killing Hipparchus, made the rest of the Peisistratids more savage and did nothing to end their tyranny... A shield was held up; that cannot be denied, for it happened. But who held it up I cannot say any more than this.'
Herodotus, Histories 6.121.1, 6.123 and 6.124.2 (adapted)
Using details from Passage B, how accurate do you think Herodotus' defence of the Alcmaeonids is?
Model answer
Herodotus' defence of the Alcmaeonids is not very reliable, although parts of it are supported. He wrote some fifty or sixty years later, when Pericles, whose mother came from the Alcmaeonid family, led Athens, a city Herodotus knew well, so he may have absorbed the family's version. His argument rests on their character - they 'clearly hated tyrants' - rather than any evidence about who held up the shield. One of his key claims is also wrong: he says they were in exile 'for the whole time', but the archon list found in the Agora shows Cleisthenes as archon under Hippias in 525/4 BC. The Athenians themselves seem to have suspected the family, since Megacles, an Alcmaeonid, was ostracised in the 480s, when ostracism was aimed at friends of the tyrants. On the other hand, Herodotus is honest that a shield was shown and that he cannot say who showed it, and Thucydides supports his view that the Alcmaeonids, not the tyrannicides, helped end the tyranny. Overall, his defence looks biased.