'Pericles was a democratic leader who served the people, not a monarch who ruled them.'
How far do you agree with this view?
You must use and analyse the ancient sources you have studied as well as supporting your answer with your own knowledge.
Model answer
Pericles was, in law, only one of ten generals, but his influence was so great that some sources describe him almost as a monarch. In my view he was a democratic leader whose power depended on the people, even if he dominated them.
The strongest evidence that he served the people is that his power could be taken away. Thucydides (2.65) reports that in 430 BC, during the plague, the Athenians deposed him and fined him, and Plutarch says the fine was between fifteen and fifty talents. A monarch could not be removed like this. He also had to win votes in the assembly: Plutarch (14) describes how, when Thucydides son of Melesias attacked the cost of the buildings, Pericles offered to pay himself and the people voted him the money. His policies, such as jury pay (Aristotle 27), paid rowing in the fleet and work on the building programme, gave poor citizens income and a share in public life, which fits Pericles' claim in the Funeral Oration that power is in the hands of the many and poverty is no bar. Nor was he above the law: his friend Pheidias was prosecuted and, according to Plutarch, died in prison, and Aspasia was put on trial, and Plutarch (31-32) says Pericles could only plead for her with tears before the jurors.
On the other hand, Thucydides himself concluded that 'what was nominally a democracy became in his hands government by the first citizen' (2.65.9). Plutarch quotes comic poets who called his friends 'new Peisistratidae' and said the Athenians had handed him the cities and their tribute (16), and Aristophanes shows 'Pericles the Olympian' thundering like Zeus. Plutarch also suggests he chose the people's side 'against his own nature' to defeat Cimon, and Aristotle saw jury pay as a bid for popularity. His use of ostracism to remove Cimon and Thucydides also suggests a politician securing control, and Plutarch (16.3) says that after Thucydides' exile he held an unbroken power for fifteen years through his annual generalship.
The reliability of these sources matters. Thucydides admired Pericles and wrote after the disasters that followed his death, so he stresses Pericles' control to contrast him with the 'whims of the multitude' under later leaders. The comic poets exaggerated for laughs, although their jokes only worked if the audience recognised his power. Plutarch, writing about 550 years later, admits that the truth about Pericles is hard to find and mixes praise with hostile stories. Aristotle's school disliked popular leaders.
Overall, I largely agree with the statement. Pericles led rather than followed the people, as Thucydides says, but he did so through persuasion and re-election. The fact that the assembly could fine and depose him shows he served at the people's will rather than ruling as a monarch.
Explanation
High-level answers balance the formal limits on Pericles (annual election, deposition and fine in 430) against the evidence of his dominance, using named sources and judging their reliability (Thucydides' admiration, comedy's exaggeration, Plutarch's distance and moral aims). Answers that only tell the story of his career, or never question a source, cannot go beyond Level 2.