'Pericles' Funeral Oration shows the Athenians as they really were.'
How far do you agree with this view?
You must use and analyse the ancient sources you have studied as well as supporting your answer with your own knowledge.
Model answer
The Funeral Oration shows how the Athenians wanted to see themselves, and much of it was true, but it is an idealised picture that leaves out a great deal. I agree with the statement only partly.
Some of its claims are supported by other evidence. Pericles says that Athens is a democracy run in the interests of the many, where even busy men judge public affairs and a man who takes no part is 'useless'. Aristotle's description of the council, the assembly and the courts, with hundreds of ordinary citizens chosen by lot, shows that participation was real. Pericles' claim that Athens holds 'games and sacrifices all through the year' is confirmed by the Panathenaia, shown on the Parthenon frieze and its prize amphorae, and by the City Dionysia. Athens was open to foreigners: metics such as Aspasia of Miletus lived and taught there. The public funeral itself, and the promise to raise the war orphans at public expense, were real practices. His claim that Athens was 'an education to Greece' fits the buildings, drama and philosophy of the time, and visitors and teachers such as Protagoras did come to Athens from all over the Greek world. Even his praise of Athenians who are 'good judges of public affairs' is supported by the large juries and the regular assemblies that made ordinary men decide important questions.
However, much is missing or exaggerated. The speech was a speech of praise at a state funeral, designed to inspire the citizens to fight on, and Thucydides admits that he wrote speeches in his own words. It speaks only of male citizens: women are told that their greatest glory is to be 'least talked of', and slaves and metics had no political rights. Its picture of tolerance hardly fits the prosecutions of Pheidias and Aspasia, which Plutarch describes, or the use of ostracism. Pericles boasts of making friends 'by doing favours', but in another speech he admits that the empire earned 'hatred'. Thucydides himself undermines the speech: immediately afterwards he describes the plague, when Athenians ignored the laws and the gods, and he later says the democracy was really 'government by the first citizen'.
The nature of the sources explains this. Thucydides was probably present and knew Pericles' views, so the ideas are probably Pericles' own, but he placed the speech deliberately before the plague, perhaps to contrast the ideal with the reality. Plutarch wrote much later and repeated hostile stories, so his trials must be used with care. The amphorae and the frieze are genuine evidence of festivals but are themselves official, idealised images.
Overall, the Funeral Oration shows the Athenians' ideals and many real features of their city, but not 'as they really were': it leaves out those excluded from citizenship, the harsh side of the empire and the fragility of their values under pressure.
Explanation
High-level answers test particular claims of the Funeral Oration (democracy, festivals, openness, culture) against other evidence and identify what it omits (women, slaves, empire, intolerance, the plague), while evaluating Thucydides' method and purpose. One-sided answers are capped at 12.