'The ancient writers tell us more about their own times than about Alexander.'
How far do you agree with this view?
You must use and analyse the ancient sources you have studied as well as supporting your answer with your own knowledge.
Model answer
The ancient writers certainly reveal a great deal about their own times, but I do not agree that they tell us more about those times than about Alexander, because much of their information comes from sources written in Alexander's lifetime.
There is good evidence for the statement. All our main narratives were written centuries after Alexander: Diodorus in the 1st century BC, and Plutarch and Arrian in the 2nd century AD under Roman emperors. Their interests show through. Arrian repeatedly comments on how flatterers corrupt kings, criticising Anaxarchus for telling Alexander that whatever a king does is just, and he praises Alexander for repenting of his errors, issues that mattered under emperors such as Hadrian. Arrian also tells us about himself: he wanted to be Alexander's Homer and to rank among the first writers in Greek. Plutarch, a priest at Delphi, fills his account with omens and moral lessons, such as his warning about superstition at the end of Alexander's life, and Diodorus presents Philip's death as fate foretold by an oracle. Speeches such as Callisthenes' attack on prostration were probably composed by the writers themselves.
However, these writers relied on sources from Alexander's time. Arrian names Ptolemy and Aristobulus, who were on the expedition, and cites the Royal Diary for Alexander's last illness; Plutarch quotes the Journals, Callisthenes and Eratosthenes. Their details can sometimes be checked. Plutarch says Gaugamela was fought eleven nights after an eclipse of the moon, and the Babylonian Astronomical Diary, written at the time by Babylonian scholars, confirms the eclipse and Darius' defeat. Arrian's detailed account of the battle line at Gaugamela is precise and consistent with what follows.
The writers were also critical, which shows they were trying to find out about Alexander rather than simply using him. Arrian says burning Persepolis was not sensible, and he warns that writers about Hephaestion's death wrote out of 'goodwill or envy'. Plutarch rejects invented tragic stories about Alexander's death and reports that most writers thought the poison story was made up.
Of course, their contemporary sources had biases too: Ptolemy may have exaggerated his own role, and Callisthenes flattered the king. The archaeological evidence, such as the coins of Lysimachus and Ptolemy, shows that even in the generation after his death Alexander's image was shaped for political purposes.
Overall, the writers' own times influenced what they chose to stress and how they judged Alexander, but their narratives are built on contemporary evidence that can often be confirmed. They tell us about both, but more about Alexander, provided we read them with their contexts and their sources in mind.