'The Athenian empire benefited the allies as much as it benefited Athens.'
How far do you agree with this view?
You must use and analyse the ancient sources you have studied as well as supporting your answer with your own knowledge.
Model answer
The allies gained real benefits from the empire, but Athens gained much more, and on Athens' terms. I disagree with the statement.
The allies did benefit in some ways. The League was formed in 478/7 BC because the Greeks of the islands and Asia Minor wanted protection from Persia and were tired of the Spartan Pausanias. Thucydides says they joined willingly, and Aristides' assessment of 460 talents was remembered as fair. Athens did keep Persia away: Pericles argued, according to Plutarch, that Athens owed the allies no account of the money 'so long as' it 'kept the barbarians away'. The Aegean became safer for trade, and in the Funeral Oration Pericles boasts that goods from every land flowed into Athens' harbour, a trade network the allies shared. Many allied cities were democracies, and their poorer citizens often supported Athens.
However, Athens gained far more. Its officials controlled the money from the start, and in 454 BC the treasury moved to Athens. Plutarch reports that Pericles' opponents complained that Athens was spending the allies' money 'gilding and decorating' the city, and Pericles himself said the money belonged 'to those who receive it'. The allies lost their freedom: when Thasos revolted it had to give up its walls, its ships and its mine, and Samos was besieged until it surrendered in the ninth month. The Brea decree shows Athens ordering allied cities to defend Athenian colonists and settling poorer Athenians on land in the empire. In Thucydides, Pericles admits that Athens has earned 'hatred' by ruling. Athens' democracy and buildings were paid for by tribute, which fed thousands of rowers, jurors and craftsmen. Meanwhile the League's original purpose shrank: after the victory at the Eurymedon and the later peace with Persia the danger had faded, yet Athens kept collecting tribute. By 431 BC, Thucydides says, it brought in about 600 talents a year, and a reserve of 6,000 talents had built up on the Acropolis, money that served Athens' war with Sparta, not the allies' defence against Persia.
The sources make the allies' view hard to judge. Thucydides was an Athenian, though unusually frank about power, and Pericles' speeches are written in his words. Plutarch, writing about AD 100, reports criticisms made by Athenians such as Thucydides son of Melesias, not by allies. The Brea decree is a reliable contemporary record, but it shows only what Athens decided. Almost no evidence from the allies themselves survives, so their gains may be underestimated, but their revolts show that many resented Athenian rule.
Overall, the empire gave the allies security and trade, but Athens took their money, controlled their policies and punished their revolts, so it benefited Athens far more than the allies.
Explanation
High-level answers weigh benefits to the allies (protection, trade, democracy) against Athenian gains and control (tribute, buildings, crushed revolts, cleruchies), use Thucydides, Plutarch and the Brea decree, and notice that the evidence is almost entirely Athenian. One-sided answers are capped at 12.