Passage A
Herodotus describes what happened after the Persians captured Croesus at Sardis.
'The Persians brought Croesus to Cyrus, who built a great pyre and made Croesus climb onto it in chains, with fourteen Lydian boys beside him... As Croesus stood on the pyre, he remembered the saying of Solon, that no living man should be called happy, and called out Solon's name three times. Cyrus told his interpreters to ask who this was, and Croesus explained how Solon the Athenian had once looked at all his wealth and made light of it... When he heard this, Cyrus changed his mind: he reflected that he too was only a man, he feared retribution, and he saw that nothing in human life is secure. So he ordered the fire to be put out, but his men could no longer master the flames. Then, the Lydians say, Croesus called on Apollo, and clouds suddenly gathered in a calm sky and a violent storm put out the fire... Cyrus freed Croesus from his chains, sat him beside him and treated him with great respect.'
Herodotus, Histories 1.86-88 (adapted)
Using details from Passage A and your own knowledge, what can we learn about the way Cyrus treated Croesus after the capture of Sardis?
Model answer
The beginning of the passage suggests that Cyrus first treated Croesus brutally. He made the defeated king climb a pyre 'in chains', 'with fourteen Lydian boys beside him', which suggests a public execution or even an offering to the gods to mark his victory.
The middle of the passage shows another side of Cyrus. He was curious enough to ask through his 'interpreters' who Solon was, and when he heard Croesus' story he 'changed his mind'. Herodotus says he 'reflected that he too was only a man' and 'feared retribution', so we learn that Cyrus is presented as thoughtful, religious and able to show mercy to a fallen enemy. The rescue by Apollo is only what 'the Lydians say', so the passage shows how the Lydians liked to remember their king as a favourite of the gods.
The end shows a complete change: Cyrus 'freed Croesus from his chains, sat him beside him' and treated him 'with great respect'. My own knowledge supports this. Croesus became Cyrus' adviser: he warned him to stop his soldiers keeping the plunder of Sardis, persuaded him to disarm rather than enslave the Lydians after the revolt of Pactyes, and gave advice on the campaign against the Massagetae. This also matches Cyrus' treatment of Astyages, whom he kept at court until he died.
However, we should be careful. Herodotus wrote a century later, the story of Solon is chronologically doubtful, and other sources disagree: Bacchylides says Apollo carried Croesus away to the Hyperboreans. Overall the passage teaches that Cyrus was remembered as a king who could be both ruthless and generous to the defeated.
Explanation
Strong answers track the change in Cyrus' treatment from the chains at the start, through his change of mind in the middle, to the honour at the end, and link it to own knowledge of Croesus' role as an adviser. A common weakness is to retell the pyre story, or Solon's advice, without saying what it shows about Cyrus' treatment of Croesus.