'Artaphernes dealt well with the Ionians and the Athenians between 507 and 493 BC.'
To what extent do you agree with this view?
Spelling, punctuation and grammar and the use of specialist terminology will be assessed in this answer
Model answer
Artaphernes, Darius' brother and satrap at Sardis, dealt well with the Ionians after their revolt, but his handling of Athens and of the build-up to the revolt was poor.
His early dealings with Athens did not go well. When Athenian envoys came to Sardis in about 507 BC asking for an alliance against Sparta, he demanded earth and water for Darius. This was normal Persian practice and the envoys agreed, but they were blamed for it when they returned home, so the alliance only stored up trouble. Around 500 BC he went further, ordering the Athenians to take back the exiled tyrant Hippias if they wanted to be safe. Herodotus says that after they refused, the Athenians regarded themselves as enemies of Persia. This was a serious mistake: it helps explain why Athens sent twenty ships to help the Ionians in 499 BC.
His role in the outbreak of the revolt was also unwise. He backed Aristagoras' plan to attack Naxos and put his cousin Megabates in charge. The two commanders quarrelled, Megabates warned the Naxians, the four-month siege failed, and Aristagoras, fearing for his position, rebelled. In fairness, the plan itself was carefully prepared: he consulted Darius and provided 200 triremes, twice the number Aristagoras asked for, so its failure owed more to the quarrel between the commanders than to his planning. Then in 498 BC the rebels reached Sardis itself and burned the city and the temple of Cybebe, although Artaphernes held the citadel.
On the other hand, his response to the revolt was effective. Holding the citadel meant the rebels could not take the whole city, and Persian troops beat them near Ephesus soon after. With Otanes he retook cities such as Clazomenae and Cyme, and the Persian commanders' combination of a large fleet, divide-and-rule tactics and siege warfare ended the revolt at Lade and Miletus in 494 BC. He also acted decisively against Histiaeus, executing him at Sardis, although Herodotus says Darius blamed them for it and thinks he would have pardoned Histiaeus, so this may have been a self-interested act.
His greatest success was the settlement of 493 BC. He made the Ionian cities agree to settle their disputes by arbitration rather than raids, measured their land in parasangs and fixed tribute at about the same level as before. Herodotus, no friend of Persia, says this assessment was still in force in his own day, which shows that it was fair and lasting.
Overall, I agree only partly. Artaphernes was a capable administrator who restored order in Ionia and left a fair system, but his demands on Athens and his support for the Naxos expedition helped to start the revolt and to make Athens an enemy, problems that troubled Persia for decades.
Explanation
Strong answers judge Artaphernes on both the Ionians and the Athenians, using specific evidence such as earth and water, the Hippias ultimatum, the Naxos expedition, the defence of Sardis and the settlement of 493 BC. Weaker answers confuse the satrap with his son who commanded at Marathon, or only describe events without judging how well he dealt with them.