'Cambyses' death was the result of his own actions.'
To what extent do you agree with this view?
Spelling, punctuation and grammar and the use of specialist terminology will be assessed in this answer
Model answer
Herodotus tells the death of Cambyses as the story of a king destroyed by his own crimes, and there is evidence to support this. However, the direct cause of his death was an accident, and Herodotus' account is shaped by his belief in fate and divine punishment, so I agree with the statement only in part.
The strongest case for the statement is the murder of Smerdis. Herodotus says Cambyses dreamed that his brother sat on the throne and touched the sky with his head, so he sent Prexaspes to kill him in secret. This made it possible for a Magian with the same name to seize the throne, because most Persians believed Smerdis was still alive. The Behistun inscription agrees that Cambyses killed his brother secretly. When Cambyses heard the herald, he realised he had killed his brother 'for nothing', and he was rushing to march against the Magian when he was wounded. Without the murder there would have been no crisis.
Cambyses' long absence in Egypt also mattered. He had spent about three years there, leaving a Magian in charge of his household, which gave the conspirators their chance. In Herodotus he wounds himself with his own sword as he leaps onto his horse in haste, and Ctesias also says he wounded his own thigh, while carving wood. The Behistun inscription says he 'died his own death', which some read as suicide. In Herodotus and Ctesias, at least, the wound came from his own hand.
Herodotus also sees the death as punishment. The sword struck his thigh 'in the same place where he had once struck Apis', so his sacrilege in Egypt is repaid. For Herodotus, Cambyses brought death on himself through his crimes against gods and family.
On the other hand, the wound itself was an accident: the cap fell off the sheath. Cambyses did not choose to die, and he died of an infection that ancient doctors could not cure. Herodotus himself also stresses fate: the oracle of Buto had foretold that Cambyses would die at Ecbatana, and Cambyses admits on his deathbed that no man can avert what is destined. The Magi's rebellion was their own choice, and Darius' phrase 'died his own death' may simply mean that Cambyses died naturally. Some modern historians have wondered whether the death was entirely accidental, coming so conveniently for the plotters, but there is no ancient evidence for this.
Finally, Herodotus' account follows a moral pattern of crime and punishment that he also uses for Croesus and Cyrus, so we should be cautious about the details.
In conclusion, Cambyses' actions, especially the murder of Smerdis and his long absence, created the crisis in which he died, so in that sense his death was the result of his own actions. But the wound itself was an accident, and the idea that it punished his sacrilege is Herodotus' interpretation. His own actions explain why he was in danger, not why he died.
Explanation
Level 5 answers separate the immediate cause (an accidental, self-inflicted wound) from the wider causes (the murder of Smerdis, the absence in Egypt), use more than one ancient account and reach a clear judgement. Answers that only retell Herodotus' story of the sword and the oracle are limited, and one-sided answers are capped at 12. Terms such as oracle, sacrilege and succession support the SPaG mark.