'The Peisistratids were good rulers for Athens.'
How far do you agree with this view?
You must use and analyse the ancient sources you have studied as well as supporting your answer with your own knowledge.
Model answer
Whether the Peisistratids were good rulers depends on what is meant by 'good' and on which period is examined. For most of the tyranny the sources suggest effective and popular government, but it rested on force and ended in repression.
The case for good rule is strongest for Peisistratus himself. Aristotle's Athenian Constitution describes him as mild and forgiving, lending money to poor farmers, appointing local judges and touring the countryside to settle disputes, so that his tyranny was remembered as 'the age of Cronus'. Thucydides, a careful historian who checked inscriptions, goes further and says the tyrants aimed at goodness and good sense, took only a twentieth of produce in tax, made the city beautiful, fought its wars and paid for its sacrifices. Both writers say the existing laws were kept. Thucydides' evidence is particularly valuable because he deliberately set out to correct popular Athenian myths about the tyrants, and his quotation of the Pythion altar inscription can still be checked against the stone.
However, this good government was not freely chosen. Aristotle himself shows Peisistratus seizing power by self-wounding and a bodyguard, by the Phye trick and finally by mercenaries, and then disarming the people at the Theseum. Thucydides admits that the family always made sure one of their own held office, so the 'laws' were managed for their benefit. Herodotus reports that the Alcmaeonids were in exile throughout the tyranny and that the sons had Cimon killed. In Herodotus' view (5.78) the Athenians under the tyrants were no better in war than their neighbours because they were working for a master, and only became the first of the Greeks once they were free.
The sources also agree that the rule worsened after 514 BC. Aristotle, Thucydides and Herodotus all describe Hippias' executions, exiles and suspicion after Hipparchus' murder, and Hippias' later role as guide to the Persians at Marathon hardly suggests a ruler devoted to Athens' interests.
The reliability of these sources needs care. Herodotus wrote in democratic Athens in the mid-fifth century and was hostile to tyranny in general; he may also have followed the traditions of the Alcmaeonids, the tyrants' chief enemies. Aristotle's account was written two centuries later, perhaps by a pupil, and is inconsistent: it says Peisistratus governed by the laws, yet also that Solon's laws fell out of use under the tyranny. All the literary sources were written after the democracy had turned the tyrannicides into heroes, which probably darkened memories of the tyranny's last years.
Overall, I largely agree with the statement for Peisistratus and for his sons before 514 BC: Athens was peaceful, prosperous and well governed. But the Peisistratids were good rulers on their own terms, not the Athenians', and Hippias' harsh final years and his alliance with Persia show the limits of that goodness.
Explanation
High marks need both sides, supported by named sources whose reliability is discussed in context (Thucydides' use of inscriptions, Aristotle's late date and inconsistency, Herodotus' hostility to tyrants). Answers that only retell the stories of Peisistratus' coups, or that never evaluate a source, are capped at 8.