Question 1
2 marksIdentify two ways in which Tacitus presents the Britons who resisted Rome in a positive way.
Model answer
He presents them as lovers of freedom fighting against slavery, as Calgacus does in his speech, and as dignified in defeat, like Caratacus, who did not beg for mercy at Rome.
Explanation
Tacitus often gives Rome's enemies noble qualities and powerful speeches, partly to make Roman victories greater and partly to criticise Roman greed and the loss of freedom at Rome itself. Good answers name the quality and the Briton who shows it.
Mark scheme
-
2 marks
Any two of: as lovers of freedom who fight to avoid slavery (Caratacus, Boudicca, Calgacus); as brave and determined (e.g. the Silures, 'neither terror nor mercy' changed them); as skilful leaders (Caratacus' choice of ground; Venutius 'pre-eminent in military skill'); as dignified in defeat (Caratacus' speech at Rome, refusing to beg); as noble and uncorrupted, unlike Romans softened by luxury (Calgacus: 'untouched by slavery'); as victims of Roman greed and injustice (the Iceni); as eloquent speakers (the speeches given to Caratacus, Boudicca and Calgacus)
1 mark for each different correct answer, max 2. Allow recognisable spellings. Credit any other historically valid answer. Each answer must be a way of presenting the Britons, not just an event. Two examples of the same quality (e.g. two brave tribes) score once.