Passage A
Plutarch, a Greek writer of about AD 100, discusses the stories of Rome's founding.
'Writers do not agree about who gave the great name of Rome, famous among all people, to the city, or why... Even those who say, following the most reliable tradition, that Romulus gave the city his name do not agree about his family... The story that is most widely believed and has the most witnesses was first published among the Greeks, in its main points, by Diocles of Peparethus, and Fabius Pictor follows him in most things. There are different versions here too, but in outline the story runs as follows... Most of these details are told by Fabius and by Diocles of Peparethus, who seems to have been the first to publish a "Founding of Rome". Some people are suspicious of their dramatic and invented quality. But we should not disbelieve them when we see what a poet Fortune sometimes is, and when we consider that the Roman state would never have reached its present power if it had not had a divine origin, attended by great wonders.'
Plutarch, Life of Romulus 1.1, 2.1, 3.1 and 8.7 (adapted)
Using details from Passage A and your own knowledge, what can we learn about the origins and reliability of the story of Romulus?
Model answer
The passage shows that the story of Rome's founding was disputed even in ancient times. Plutarch begins by saying that 'writers do not agree' about who named Rome or why. From my own knowledge, he and Dionysius record versions in which Rome was named after a Trojan woman called Roma or founded by a son of Aeneas. Even writers who accepted Romulus 'do not agree about his family'.
We also learn where the main version came from. It 'was first published among the Greeks ... by Diocles of Peparethus', and 'Fabius Pictor follows him in most things'. From my own knowledge, Fabius was the first Roman historian, writing in Greek around 200 BC, over five hundred years after the traditional date of 753 BC, and Livy and Dionysius both used him. So the whole tradition rests on a few late writers, one of them a Greek, rather than on records from the time.
The middle of the passage shows that the story still varied: 'there are different versions here too'. Livy, for example, gives two accounts of Remus' death and reports that the 'she-wolf' may have been a woman called Larentia.
At the end Plutarch admits that 'some people are suspicious' of the story's 'dramatic and invented quality'. His defence is weak: he says 'Fortune' can be a 'poet', and that Rome would not have become so powerful without 'a divine origin'. This argues backwards from Rome's later greatness, which is what the story was meant to explain. Livy's preface shows similar caution when he calls such stories closer to poetry than history.
Overall, we learn that the story of Romulus was a literary tradition shaped by Greek and Roman writers long afterwards. Archaeology shows huts on the Palatine in the 8th century BC, but it cannot confirm Romulus himself.
Explanation
Strong answers explain what the passage reveals about the evidence: rival versions, the dependence of Roman historians on a Greek writer, the doubts of ancient readers and Plutarch's weak defence. They add own knowledge such as Fabius' date, Livy's preface and the archaeological evidence. Retelling the Romulus story instead of discussing its origins misses the focus.