'Claudius himself contributed little to the conquest of Britain.'
How far do you agree with this view?
You must use and analyse the ancient sources you have studied as well as supporting your answer with your own knowledge.
Model answer
Claudius' personal part in the fighting was small, but his contribution to the conquest as a whole was greater than his critics allowed.
The case for the statement is strong. Dio says that Claudius was away from Rome for six months but 'spent only sixteen days in Britain'. Before he arrived, the hard fighting had been done by others: Dio describes German auxiliaries swimming the river and wounding the chariot horses, Vespasian and Sabinus crossing to attack, and Hosidius Geta winning the second day's battle. Suetonius says Claudius received the surrender of part of the island 'without any battle or bloodshed', and Josephus says Vespasian recovered Britain and won Claudius a triumph 'without any sweat or labour of his own'. After Claudius left, Vespasian campaigned in the south-west, and Plautius received an ovation, with Claudius walking at his side. However, these sources must be treated with care. Suetonius often mocks Claudius, and his 'without any battle' may be a sneer. Josephus wrote for the Flavian emperors, so he had every reason to give Vespasian the credit. Even so, the honours for Plautius suggest that the Romans themselves knew who had done the fighting.
On the other hand, Claudius made the important decisions. He launched the invasion and chose Plautius, and Dio says his freedman Narcissus was sent to deal with the army's mutiny. Dio, who had no reason to flatter Claudius 150 years later, says he took command, crossed the Thames, defeated the Britons and captured Camulodunum. More important still was his diplomacy: he 'won over numerous tribes, in some cases by capitulation, in others by force', disarmed the conquered and ordered Plautius to subdue the rest. The Arch of Claudius says he received the surrender of eleven British kings. The client kingdoms of Togidubnus, Prasutagus and Cartimandua, probably arranged at this time, helped to keep the south and north quiet for years. Of course the arch, like the coins showing his triumphal arch and chariot, is propaganda: the claim of victory 'without any loss' is an exaggeration, and the text is partly restored. But even propaganda shows that Claudius' presence mattered politically. Tacitus, who had no reason to flatter Claudius, also calls him the man who renewed the enterprise that Caesar had begun and Gaius had only planned, sending legions and auxiliaries so that 'peoples were conquered and kings captured', although Tacitus' main interest is in the rise of Vespasian.
In conclusion, I partly agree. In military terms Claudius contributed little: the battles were won by Plautius, Vespasian and their troops, and his visit was short and carefully staged. But his decision to invade, his presence at the fall of Camulodunum and the submission of the kings shaped the early province. The hostile accounts of Suetonius and Josephus exaggerate his idleness, just as his own monuments exaggerate his glory.
Explanation
The best answers separate the fighting from Claudius' political and diplomatic role, and judge each source by its purpose: Suetonius' scorn, Josephus' Flavian loyalty, Dio's distance and the arch's propaganda. Answers that only retell Dio's narrative without evaluating it stay below Level 3.