Passage A
Livy describes Servius Tullius' most famous reform.
'Servius undertook by far the greatest work of peace, so that, just as Numa had founded religious law, later generations would celebrate him as the founder of all the distinctions of rank and fortune in the state. He set up the census, so that from then on the duties of war and peace would be carried out not by everyone alike, as before, but according to wealth. Then, on the basis of the census, he created the classes and centuries... From those who had property worth 100,000 asses or more he formed eighty centuries, forty of older men and forty of younger. All these were called the first class. The older men were to be ready to guard the city, the younger to fight wars abroad. The arms required of them were a helmet, a round shield, greaves and a breastplate, all of bronze, and a spear and a sword. Two centuries of engineers were added to this class, to serve without arms and carry the siege machines in war.'
Livy, The History of Rome 1.42.4-1.43.3 (adapted)
Using details from Passage A and your own knowledge, what can we learn about Servius Tullius' reorganisation of the army?
Model answer
The passage shows that Servius' army reform was based on wealth. He set up the census so that 'the duties of war and peace' would be carried out 'not by everyone alike, as before, but according to wealth'. This created what Livy calls 'distinctions ... of rank and fortune'.
We learn that the army was organised into 'classes and centuries'. The first class, those with '100,000 asses or more', formed 'eighty centuries'. They were divided by age: 'the older men' guarded the city, while 'the younger' fought 'wars abroad'. This gave Rome both a home guard and a field army.
The passage also shows that the richest men were the most heavily armed. The first class had 'a helmet, a round shield, greaves and a breastplate, all of bronze', with 'a spear and a sword'. Because each man paid for his own armour, only the wealthy could afford this. From my own knowledge, the lower classes had less: the second had a long shield and no breastplate, the fourth only a spear and javelin, and the fifth only slings. This suggests a heavy infantry line, like the Greek hoplite phalanx, with lighter troops behind.
At the end we learn that there were specialist units, 'two centuries of engineers' to carry 'the siege machines'. From my own knowledge, there were also eighteen centuries of cavalry, paid for partly by public money and a tax on widows.
The reform also had political effects, since the army of centuries became the assembly that voted by centuries, with the rich voting first. Overall, the passage shows a carefully organised army in which wealth decided a man's place, although many historians think the full five-class system developed later and was credited to Servius.
Explanation
Top answers draw several inferences from across the passage (service based on property, classes and centuries, age groups, heavy bronze armour for the rich, specialist engineers) and add own knowledge of the other classes, the cavalry and the link to hoplite warfare and the centuriate assembly. Copying the list of armour without explaining what it shows stays in the lower levels.