'Cassius Dio is less reliable than Tacitus as a source for the Roman conquest of Britain.'
How far do you agree with this view?
You must use and analyse the ancient sources you have studied as well as supporting your answer with your own knowledge.
Model answer
Dio is generally less reliable than Tacitus, but the statement is too simple, because for the invasion of AD 43 Dio is our best source, and Tacitus has serious biases of his own.
There are good reasons to prefer Tacitus. He wrote between about AD 98 and 120, 50 to 70 years after most events, while Dio wrote about AD 200-230, more than 150 years after the conquest. Tacitus also had an exceptional informant: his father-in-law Agricola, who served on Paulinus' staff in AD 60-61 and later governed Britain. Dio does not name his sources. Dio's account of Boudicca survives only in a Byzantine summary, and it contains features that weaken it: omens such as houses seen under the Thames, a sensational description of Boudicca's appearance, long speeches full of Greek references, and huge numbers such as 230,000 Britons. His description of the final battle is generic, and it contradicts Tacitus, who explains that Paulinus chose a narrow position so that he could not be surrounded, whereas Dio says the Romans were surrounded and fought everywhere at once. Dio also ignores the outrages against Boudicca and her daughters, blaming Seneca's loans instead, perhaps because he was hostile to Seneca.
However, Dio is valuable, and sometimes essential. Tacitus' account of the invasion in the Annals is lost, so Dio's Book 60, which survives in full, is our main narrative of AD 43. It is detailed and believable: Bericus' appeal, the mutiny ended by Narcissus, the landing in three divisions, the river battle and Claudius' sixteen days in Britain. Dio was a senator, twice consul and a governor with armies, so he understood war and politics. Tacitus, meanwhile, has his own problems. The Agricola is a tribute to his father-in-law, so it exaggerates Agricola's achievements and dismisses Bolanus; the speeches of Calgacus and Boudicca are his own compositions; and he moralises, presenting Cartimandua's 'passion and cruelty' and Romanisation as 'part of their slavery'. Both writers used earlier histories that are now lost, and both write from a Roman viewpoint with no British voice.
Archaeology can help to judge them. The destruction layers in Colchester, London and St Albans confirm the scale of the revolt that both describe, and the Arch of Claudius supports Dio's picture of tribes submitting to Claudius. Where the two writers can be compared directly, they often agree on the main events, such as Paulinus being away on Mona when the revolt began and the Romans winning a hard battle late in the day, which suggests that both drew on a reliable tradition and that the differences lie mainly in detail and colour. Dio's numbers are larger and his scenes more dramatic, but the figure Tacitus reports from 'some' writers, of almost 80,000 British dead for about 400 Romans, is hardly more believable.
Overall, I largely agree for the events of AD 60-84, where Tacitus' closeness to the events and his link with Agricola make him more reliable than Dio's later and summarised account. But for AD 43 Dio is more useful than Tacitus, whose account is lost, and Tacitus' own purposes mean that neither writer can be trusted without checking.