Passage D
Tacitus describes what Suetonius Paulinus did after Camulodunum had fallen to the rebels in AD 60 or 61.
'But Suetonius, with remarkable determination, marched through the midst of the enemy to Londinium, which was not distinguished by the title of colony, but was very busy with crowds of merchants and goods. ... Looking at the small number of his soldiers, and having seen clearly how Petillius' rashness had been punished, he decided to save the whole province at the cost of one town. Unmoved by the people's tears and pleas, he gave the signal to march, and took into his column those who could go with him. Those who stayed behind, because they were women, or too old, or attached to the place, were overwhelmed by the enemy. The town of Verulamium suffered the same disaster, because the barbarians, delighting in plunder and careless of everything else, passed by the forts with garrisons and made for whatever was richest for looters and unsafe for defenders. About seventy thousand citizens and allies, it is agreed, died in the places I have mentioned.'
Tacitus, Annals 14.33 (adapted)
Using details from Passage D, how accurate do you think Tacitus' account of what happened at Londinium and Verulamium is?
Model answer
Tacitus' account is largely accurate, although it may be sympathetic to Paulinus. Archaeology supports it: a layer of burnt debris dating to about AD 60-61 has been found in London, Colchester and St Albans, confirming the destruction, and early London was indeed a trading town 'very busy with crowds of merchants and goods'. Tacitus also had an inside source, since his father-in-law Agricola served on Paulinus' staff during the revolt. However, that connection may explain the praise of Paulinus' 'remarkable determination' and the justification that he chose to 'save the whole province at the cost of one town'. The figure of 'about seventy thousand' dead is a large round number, similar to Dio's 80,000, and may be exaggerated. The description of 'barbarians, delighting in plunder' is a Roman stereotype. Overall, the events are reliable, but the judgements favour Paulinus.