Question 1
2 marksIdentify two terms of the Treaty of Lutatius (241 BC), which ended the First Punic War.
Model answer
Carthage had to leave the whole of Sicily, and it had to pay Rome a large indemnity (3,200 talents in the final version).
Explanation
Polybius gives the terms twice (1.62-63 and 3.27): Carthage gave up Sicily and the nearby islands, paid an indemnity, released prisoners without ransom and left Rome's allies alone. Students often confuse these terms with the later seizure of Sardinia (238/237 BC) or with the much harsher peace of 201 BC, which do not count here.
Mark scheme
-
2 marks
Any two of: Carthage was to leave (evacuate) the whole of Sicily; Carthage was to give up the islands between Sicily and Italy; Carthage was to pay Rome an indemnity / war payment (first set at 2,200 talents over 20 years, then raised to 3,200 talents: 1,000 at once and 2,200 over 10 years); Carthage was to return all Roman prisoners without ransom; Carthage was not to make war on Hiero / Syracuse or its allies (the allies of each side were to be safe from attack by the other); neither side was to recruit soldiers, raise money or make alliances in the other's territory or with the other's allies
1 mark for each different correct answer, max 2. Allow recognisable spellings. Credit an indemnity answer without the exact sum ('Carthage had to pay Rome a large sum of money'). Credit any other historically valid term.
Do not credit: giving up Sardinia or paying the extra 1,200 talents (these were forced on Carthage later, in 238/237 BC); handing over Iberia or Hannibal; giving up the fleet or elephants or not making war without Rome's permission (terms of the peace of 201 BC, after the Second Punic War).