'The consuls of the early Republic were simply kings under another name.'
To what extent do you agree with this view?
Spelling, punctuation and grammar and the use of specialist terminology will be assessed in this answer
Model answer
There is some truth in the view that the first consuls were kings under another name. Livy himself says that the first consuls 'kept all the rights and all the symbols of the kings', and that liberty began because office became annual rather than because power was reduced. Like the kings, the consuls held imperium: they led the army, judged cases and could punish citizens. They were preceded by lictors carrying the fasces with axes, and sat on the curule chair. Brutus showed this power when he had his own sons executed for plotting to bring back the Tarquins, and Valerius was soon accused of being 'the heir of Tarquin's tyranny' because he ruled alone and lived in a grand house on the Velia. Later consuls could still be harsh: in 495 BC Appius Claudius handed debtors back to their creditors as harshly as he could. In emergencies the Republic even created a dictator, from whom there was no appeal, and in 451-449 BC the decemvirs behaved so tyrannically that Livy describes them as ten kings with 120 lictors.
However, the differences between kings and consuls were important. The kings ruled for life: Romulus, Numa and Servius reigned for decades, and Superbus for twenty-five years. The consuls held office for a single year and there were always two of them, who took turns with the fasces so that, as Livy says, the terror would not seem doubled. They were elected each year in the centuriate assembly, whereas Superbus seized power by murdering Servius and ruled without the vote of the people or the approval of the Senate. Valerius' laws of 509 BC gave citizens the right of appeal against a consul's sentence and allowed anyone who aimed at kingship to be killed, and he removed the axes from the fasces inside the city. The religious duties of the kings were handed to the rex sacrorum, who was kept under the pontifex.
The limits on the consuls also grew over time. After the First Secession of 494 BC the tribunes of the plebs could protect plebeians against the consuls, and consuls could be prosecuted after leaving office, as the consuls of 455 BC were. The Senate became more powerful than it had been under the later kings: in 494 the dictator Manius Valerius resigned when the Senate refused his debt reforms, and the Valerio-Horatian laws of 449 BC restored the right of appeal after the decemvirs' tyranny. Kings such as Tarquinius Superbus had no such checks at all.
We should also remember that the sources are late. Livy wrote nearly five hundred years after 509 BC and may have imagined the early consulship as like the office of his own day; some writers suggest the chief magistrates were at first called praetors. But even so, the main features of the change are well supported.
Overall, the statement is only partly true. In 509 BC the consuls inherited the kings' power and symbols almost unchanged, so they did resemble kings for a year at a time. But the principles of annual office, colleagues, election and appeal, and later the tribunes, meant that by 440 BC the consuls were far more limited than any king had been. They were kings in their insignia, but not in the way they held or used power.
Explanation
High-level essays compare specific kings with specific consuls across the eras rather than describing the Republic only, and they weigh continuities (imperium, fasces, harsh punishments) against real changes (annual office, collegiality, appeal, tribunes) before reaching a clear judgement. Answers that only describe the creation of the consulship in 509 BC, without the kings, are capped.