Passage D
Tacitus describes the first campaign of his father-in-law Agricola, who arrived in Britain as governor in the middle of summer in AD 77 or 78.
'Shortly before his arrival, the Ordovices had almost wiped out a unit of cavalry stationed in their territory ... Although the summer was over and his units were scattered, Agricola decided to face the danger. He gathered detachments from the legions and a small force of auxiliaries, and because the Ordovices did not dare to come down onto level ground, he led the line up the slope himself, at the front, so that the others would share his courage by sharing his danger. Almost the whole tribe was cut down. Knowing that his reputation must be followed up, he decided to take the island of Mona. He had no ships ... but he sent across the pick of his auxiliaries, who knew the shallows and could swim while controlling themselves, their weapons and their horses. They attacked so suddenly that the astonished enemy, who were expecting a fleet, asked for peace and surrendered the island.'
Tacitus, Agricola 18 (adapted)
What can we learn from Passage D about Agricola's tactics in his first campaign as governor?
Model answer
Passage D shows that Agricola relied on speed, surprise and personal leadership. Although 'the summer was over' and his troops were 'scattered', he 'decided to face the danger' at once, using a small force of 'detachments from the legions' and auxiliaries. When the Ordovices stayed on the high ground, he 'led the line up the slope himself, at the front', so that his men would 'share his courage by sharing his danger'. His force was ruthless: 'Almost the whole tribe was cut down', which was meant to frighten other tribes. Agricola then followed up his success at once. Lacking ships, he sent 'the pick of his auxiliaries', who could swim with their horses and weapons, across to Mona, and the surprise was so great that the enemy, 'expecting a fleet', 'surrendered the island'.
Explanation
The best answers explain several tactics: acting quickly out of season, leading from the front, ruthless force, following up success and improvising with swimming auxiliaries to achieve surprise. Simply retelling the campaign without explaining the tactics stays in the lower levels.