Passage A
In 458 BC the Aequi had trapped a Roman consul and his army on Mount Algidus. Livy describes how the Senate chose a dictator to rescue them.
'What follows deserves the attention of those who despise everything human compared with wealth... The one hope of the Roman people's empire, Lucius Quinctius, was farming a field of four iugera [about one hectare] across the Tiber... There the envoys found him digging a ditch or ploughing - at any rate, as everyone agrees, busy with work on the land. After greetings, they asked him to put on his toga to hear the Senate's instructions. Surprised, he asked whether all was well, and told his wife Racilia to fetch his toga quickly from their cottage. When he had wiped off the dust and sweat and put it on, the envoys hailed him as dictator... His three sons came to meet him, then his other relatives and friends, then most of the senators... A great crowd of plebeians also gathered, but they were far from pleased to see Quinctius: they thought his power was too great, and the man himself even more dangerous than his power.'
Livy, The History of Rome 3.26.7-12 (adapted)
Using details from Passage A and your own knowledge, what can we learn about the lives of patricians, and their relations with the plebeians, in the mid-fifth century BC?
Model answer
The passage suggests that some patricians lived simple lives. Cincinnatus, 'the one hope of the Roman people's empire', was 'farming a field of four iugera across the Tiber', and the envoys found him 'digging a ditch... or ploughing', so even a leading patrician might work his own small farm. His wife Racilia fetched his toga 'from their cottage', which suggests a modest home. From own knowledge, his poverty may have been recent: when his son Caeso Quinctius fled into exile after being prosecuted by the tribunes in 461 BC, Cincinnatus had to pay the sureties and sold his property.
However, the passage also shows the power of patricians. In a crisis the Senate turned to one of them and 'hailed him as dictator', giving him supreme power. He was met by 'his three sons... his other relatives and friends... most of the senators', which shows the strength of patrician family and political networks. He then rescued the consul Minucius' army from the Aequi, triumphed and resigned after sixteen days.
We also learn about relations with the plebeians. The 'great crowd of plebeians' was 'far from pleased', because they thought 'his power was too great, and the man himself even more dangerous than his power'. This fits own knowledge: Cincinnatus was a fierce opponent of the tribunes, his son had led young patricians in attacks on them, and the dictator was free from appeal. Later, in 439, Cincinnatus was made dictator again to deal with Spurius Maelius, who was killed by his master of horse.
Finally, Livy tells the story as a moral lesson for 'those who despise everything human compared with wealth', so he may have idealised patrician simplicity to criticise the luxury of his own time.
Explanation
High-level answers draw out what the passage shows about patrician lifestyles (small farms, manual work, modest homes), patrician power (the dictatorship, family networks) and plebeian distrust, using details from the start, middle and end, and add own knowledge such as Caeso Quinctius and the 458 campaign. Noting Livy's moral purpose earns AO3 credit.