'Tarquinius Superbus was the most successful of Rome's kings in war.'
To what extent do you agree with this view?
Spelling, punctuation and grammar and the use of specialist terminology will be assessed in this answer
Model answer
Tarquinius Superbus has a strong claim to have been the most successful king in war, because by the end of his reign Rome dominated Latium. However, some of his success depended on trickery, his control did not last, and several earlier kings, especially Romulus, Tullus Hostilius and Servius Tullius, won equally important victories.
The case for Superbus is strong. Even Livy, who presents him as a tyrant, says he was 'not a bad general in war' and would have equalled the earlier kings if his wickedness had not spoiled his reputation. He began the long war with the Volsci and took Suessa Pometia by storm; its spoils paid for the temple of Jupiter. He gained control of the Latins: after Turnus Herdonius was framed and killed, the Latins renewed their treaty with Rome, and Superbus combined their young men with Romans in units under Roman centurions. He took Gabii, founded colonies at Signia and Circeii, made peace with the Aequi and renewed the treaty with the Etruscans. Polybius records a treaty between Rome and Carthage in 509 BC that lists Latin coastal towns such as Ardea, Antium and Circeii as under Roman control, which suggests that Rome really had become the leading power in Latium.
However, his record has weaknesses. He failed to take Gabii by storm or siege and won it only through Sextus' deceit, which Livy calls 'a most un-Roman method'. His attack on Ardea was driven by his need for money and was still unfinished when he was overthrown. His wars and buildings also caused hardship and resentment at home. His control did not last: after his exile, Veii and Tarquinii fought Rome at Silva Arsia, Lars Porsena besieged the city, and the Latins fought Rome at Lake Regillus.
Other kings' achievements were equally important. Romulus won the wars that allowed the city to survive, defeating Caenina, Antemnae, the Sabines, Fidenae and Veii. Tullus Hostilius destroyed Alba Longa, doubling Rome's citizens and making it the leading Latin city. Ancus took Latin towns and extended Rome to the sea. Tarquinius Priscus conquered many Latin towns and the Sabines and doubled the cavalry, and Servius Tullius fought a twenty-year war with the Etruscans and, according to Dionysius, celebrated three triumphs.
We should also remember that the tradition is hostile to Superbus, so his successes may be played down, while the earlier kings' wars are largely legendary.
In conclusion, Superbus brought Rome to its greatest power under the kings, and in that sense he was the most successful. But his methods were questionable and his control collapsed when he fell, whereas Tullus' destruction of Alba had a permanent effect. So I largely, but not completely, agree with the statement.
Explanation
High-level essays compare Superbus' victories (Suessa Pometia, Gabii, the Latin League, the colonies) with those of kings from both eras and judge 'success' by results, methods and permanence. The best note the treaty with Carthage and the hostile tradition. A narrative of Superbus' wars alone is capped.