'Hannibal's decision not to march on Rome after Cannae was the main reason why he failed to win the war.'
How far do you agree with this view?
You must use and analyse the ancient sources you have studied as well as supporting your answer with your own knowledge.
Model answer
Hannibal's failure to march on Rome after Cannae is the most famous 'what if' of the war, but I do not think it was the main reason for his defeat, because a march was probably impossible and Rome's strengths would have defeated him anyway.
The case for the statement rests mainly on Livy. He describes Maharbal urging Hannibal to follow the cavalry at once, promising that he would 'feast as victor on the Capitol' in five days, and then telling him, 'You know how to win a victory, Hannibal; you do not know how to use it.' Livy adds that it was widely believed that the delay of that day saved the city and the empire. When Hannibal left Italy in 203 BC, Livy says he cursed himself for not leading his army straight from Cannae to Rome. Rome certainly recovered quickly afterwards, and by 211 BC it was strong enough to send troops to Iberia while Hannibal camped at its walls.
However, these sources must be used carefully. The Maharbal scene is in polished direct speech and Livy presents the result only as what is 'believed', a judgement made with hindsight. The story is old, since Cato told a version of it, but Polybius, who wrote much closer to the time, does not mention it. Hannibal's regrets in Livy 30.20 are also reported as what he is said to have done, and they fit Livy's dramatic purpose.
The practical problems were enormous. Rome was about 400 km from Cannae, protected by strong walls, and Hannibal had no siege engines and an exhausted army. When he did march on Rome in 211 BC, Livy shows that the Romans met him with armies and refused to abandon the siege of Capua. Their confidence, selling the land he camped on at full price, shows how difficult a siege would have been even earlier. After Cannae Rome quickly raised new legions, even enlisting slaves, and it could call on the Latin colonies around the city.
The deeper reasons for his failure were Rome's resources and strategy. Polybius explains that Fabius recognised Rome's advantage in men and supplies, and Plutarch describes how Fabius wore Hannibal down by refusing battle. Hannibal could not protect his Italian allies, as the angry letter from Capua shows, and he received few reinforcements because the Scipios defeated Hasdrubal in Iberia in 215 BC, which Livy says the Romans welcomed more than the victory itself. Finally, Scipio's invasion of Africa forced Carthage to recall him.
In conclusion, the decision after Cannae may have been a missed opportunity, but the sources that make it decisive are dramatic and written with hindsight. Rome's manpower, its loyal allies, the Fabian strategy and the war in Iberia and Africa were far more important reasons for Hannibal's failure.
Explanation
A top answer evaluates the Maharbal story and Hannibal's later regrets as sources (direct speech, hindsight, Livy's purpose, Polybius' silence) and weighs the decision against other reasons for failure such as Rome's resources, the Fabian strategy and the loss of Iberia.