Level:
Correct: 0
Incorrect: 0
Marks: 0/0
Exam Practice
Course:
Topics:
OCR GCSE Ancient History (Rome and its neighbours) Smart practice A mixed round aimed at your weak spots
Unit 1
The foundations of Rome: from kingship to republic, 753-440 BC (longer period study)
Unit 2
Hannibal and the Second Punic War, 218-201 BC (depth study)
Unit 3
Cleopatra: Rome and Egypt, 69-30 BC (depth study)
Unit 4
Britannia: from conquest to province, AD 43-c.84 (depth study)
Avg
score:
–
Topics
done:
0/45

Roman commanders and Roman mistakes, 218-216 BC

Practise 12 exam-style questions on Roman commanders and Roman mistakes, 218-216 BC for OCR GCSE Ancient History (Rome and its neighbours). Write your answer as you would in the exam and get it marked in seconds against the mark scheme, point by point, with the Study Helper on hand if you get stuck.

  • 12 questions
  • 2–20 marks each
  • Instant marking
  • No sign-up needed
12 questions, marked as you go

Sample questions with model answers

Here are 4 of the questions in this topic, each with a model answer, an explanation of why it earns the marks and the mark scheme an examiner would use.

Question 1

2 marks

Give two mistakes made by the consul Sempronius at the Battle of the Trebia.

Model answer

He was provoked by the Numidians into leading out his whole army without breakfast, and he made his men wade the freezing river, so they were cold and weak before the battle began.

Explanation

Livy (21.54) and Polybius (3.70-72) show Sempronius eager for glory before his colleague Scipio recovered from his wound. He took Hannibal's bait, sent out his men unfed in the snow and led them through the icy Trebia, then walked into Mago's ambush. Any two different errors score.

Mark scheme
  1. 2 marks

    Any two of: he was too eager to fight / fought against the advice of his colleague Scipio (who wanted to wait); he was provoked into battle by the Numidian cavalry; he sent his men out early without breakfast / food; he made them wade the icy, swollen river in winter, so they were cold and exhausted; he sent his cavalry out first, tiring them chasing the Numidians; he did not scout the ground / fell into Mago's ambush; he fought on ground chosen by Hannibal

    1 mark for each different correct mistake, max 2. Credit any other historically valid answer. Do not credit mistakes made at other battles (the mist at Trasimene, alternating command at Cannae).

Question 2

5 marks

Passage B

In 217 BC Hannibal enters Etruria, where the consul Flaminius is camped at Arretium.

'Hannibal learned that the country ahead promised rich plunder, and that Flaminius was a thorough flatterer of the people and a demagogue, with no talent for the practical business of war, and very sure of himself besides. He calculated that if he marched past the Roman army into the country beyond, the consul would never stand by while it was laid waste, for fear of being mocked by his soldiers ... When the smoke rising on all sides showed the destruction, Flaminius grew furious. Some of his officers advised him not to chase the enemy at once but to beware of their cavalry and, above all, to wait for his fellow consul and fight with all their legions together. He would not even listen, and asked them what would be said in Rome if the country was laid waste almost to the walls while the army sat in camp behind the enemy. Then he broke camp and advanced, regardless of time or place, as if victory were certain.'

Polybius, The Histories 3.80.3-4 and 3.82.3-7 (adapted)

What can we learn from Passage B about the leadership of Flaminius?

Model answer

The passage presents Flaminius as a poor and rash leader. Polybius calls him a 'flatterer of the people and a demagogue' with 'no talent for the practical business of war', so he was a politician rather than a soldier. Hannibal could predict his behaviour: he would not let the country be ravaged 'for fear of being mocked by his soldiers', which shows that he cared about his reputation. When the smoke of burning farms appeared he 'grew furious', so he acted from anger. His officers gave sound advice, to wait for his colleague and fight 'with all their legions together', but he 'would not even listen' and worried instead about 'what would be said in Rome', which shows political pressure overriding judgement. Finally, he advanced 'regardless of time or place, as if victory were certain', the over-confidence that led him into the ambush at Trasimene.

Explanation

Strong answers explain several features of Flaminius' leadership (popular politics, lack of military skill, anger, refusal of advice, concern for opinion in Rome, over-confidence) from across the passage. Simply retelling the Battle of Trasimene without using the passage stays in Level 1.

Mark scheme
  1. 5 marks

    Levels of response (5 marks, AO3).
    Level 3 (4-5 marks): Response uses a range of fully appropriate details from the passage, which are analysed to draw out relevant characteristics and features and give a detailed and sophisticated evaluation of what we can learn from the source about the specified issue in the question.
    Level 2 (2-3 marks): Response uses some appropriate details from the passage, which are analysed to draw out some of the characteristics and features and evaluate what we can learn from the source about the specified issue in the question.
    Level 1 (1 mark): Response uses few details from the passage and makes a very basic attempt to draw out any of the characteristics and features in relation to the question.
    0 marks: No response or no response worthy of credit.

    Max 1 if the answer makes no use of the passage (own knowledge alone does not answer this question).
    Details must be explained, not just copied: credit what each detail tells us about the issue. A Level 3 answer explains a range of details from across the passage; a Level 1 answer only picks out or copies a detail or two. Own knowledge may be used to explain a detail but is not required.
    Candidates are likely to pick out and explain: 'flatterer of the people and a demagogue': Flaminius was a popular politician whose career depended on pleasing the people; 'no talent for the practical business of war': Polybius thinks he lacked military skill; 'very sure of himself': over-confidence made him predictable; 'for fear of being mocked by his soldiers': he cared about his reputation more than strategy - Hannibal could exploit this; 'Flaminius grew furious': he acted from anger rather than calculation; 'officers advised him ... to wait for his fellow consul ... all their legions together': he had sensible advice available; 'He would not even listen': he refused to take advice from his officers; 'what would be said in Rome': he was driven by political pressure and public opinion; 'regardless of time or place, as if victory were certain': rashness and over-confidence led him into Hannibal's trap at Trasimene.

Question 3

5 marks

Passage B

In 217 BC a tribune proposes that Minucius, Fabius' master of horse, should be given power equal to the dictator Fabius. Livy introduces one supporter of the proposal.

'One man was found to speak for the law: Gaius Terentius Varro, who had been praetor the year before, a man of humble and even lowly birth. They say that his father was a butcher who peddled his own meat and used his son in the menial work of that trade. When his father left him the money made from this business, the young man hoped for a more respectable position. He took up the toga and the Forum, and by loudly defending low men and their causes, and attacking the property and reputation of good citizens, he became known to the people and then won office. After holding the quaestorship, both aedileships and finally the praetorship, he now set his hopes on the consulship, and he cleverly sought the breeze of popular favour from the people's hatred of the dictator, and took for himself alone the credit for the people's decision.'

Livy, The History of Rome 22.25.18-22.26.4 (adapted)

Using details from Passage B, how accurate do you think Livy's account of Varro is?

Model answer

Livy's account of Varro is reliable on his career but probably biased about his character and background. The list of offices he held, 'the quaestorship, both aedileships and finally the praetorship', probably comes from official records and shows that Varro had a normal, successful career. However, Livy only says 'They say that his father was a butcher', so he is passing on a story, and it comes from an aristocratic tradition that blamed Varro, a new man and popular politician, for Cannae. The language is also loaded: Varro defends 'low men', attacks 'good citizens' and 'cleverly sought the breeze of popular favour', which reflects Livy's dislike of demagogues, writing under Augustus. With hindsight, Livy introduces the future commander at Cannae in the worst light. Yet Livy himself later records that the senate thanked Varro after Cannae, which suggests this portrait is exaggerated.

Explanation

The best answers separate the factual content (offices held) from the hostile story about Varro's birth and the loaded language, explaining why Livy and his sources were biased against a popular politician blamed for Cannae. Saying only that 'Livy was biased' without reference to the passage earns Level 1.

Mark scheme
  1. 5 marks

    Levels of response (5 marks, AO3).
    Level 3 (4-5 marks): Response analyses the source by using relevant detail from the source content or historical context to give a more detailed evaluation of the source within its historical context. It draws a thorough and convincing conclusion about its accuracy or reliability based on how the context in which it was created impacts on how it portrays issues or events.
    Level 2 (2-3 marks): Response analyses the source by using relevant detail from the source content or historical context to give a basic evaluation of the source within its historical context. It draws a basic conclusion about its accuracy or reliability based on how the context in which it was created impacts on how it portrays issues or events.
    Level 1 (1 mark): Response analyses the source in a basic way by selecting relevant detail from the source content or historical context.
    0 marks: No response or no response worthy of credit.

    Max 1 if the answer reaches no conclusion at all about how accurate or reliable the passage is.
    Full marks need the evaluation to be related to the particular events in the passage, not only general comments about the author. A conclusion that the passage is accurate, inaccurate or partly accurate can all reach Level 3 if it is supported. Treat bare assertions such as 'he was not there' or 'he was biased' with care: on their own they are Level 1.
    Candidates might comment on: 'They say that his father was a butcher' - Livy reports this as a story, not as a fact he has checked; Varro was a new man (the first of his family to reach high office) and a popular politician who was blamed for Cannae; the aristocratic tradition (senators such as Fabius Pictor) was hostile to him, so stories about his low birth may be slander; the list of offices (quaestor, both aedileships, praetor) probably comes from official records and shows that Varro had a normal, successful political career - not the career of an upstart; loaded language ('low men', 'good citizens', 'loudly', 'cleverly sought the breeze of popular favour') shows Livy's own hostility to popular politicians; Livy wrote under Augustus, who presented himself as restoring order after the popular politicians of the late Republic; Livy's history uses figures like Varro as moral warnings; Livy is writing with hindsight: knowing Varro would command at Cannae, he introduces him in the worst light; after Cannae, Livy himself says the senate thanked Varro for not despairing of the state, and Varro held later commands, which suggests he was not regarded as a disgrace; Polybius does not tell this story of Varro's birth.

Question 4

20 marks

'Rome's defeats in 218-216 BC were caused mainly by the rashness of its commanders.'

To what extent do you agree with this view?

You must use and analyse the ancient sources you have studied as well as supporting your answer with your own knowledge.

Model answer

Rash Roman commanders certainly contributed to the defeats of 218-216 BC, but Hannibal's skill and weaknesses in the Roman system were just as important, so I only partly agree.

The case for rashness is strong in the sources. At the Trebia, Livy shows Sempronius rushing out his whole army after the Numidian horsemen, with his men unfed and soaked by the icy river. Polybius describes Flaminius as over-confident and furious when Hannibal ravaged Etruria; he ignored his officers' advice to wait for his colleague and advanced 'as if victory were certain' into the ambush at Trasimene. Before Cannae, Livy shows Varro mocking Fabius' caution and giving the signal for battle without consulting Paullus. Even Paullus, in Livy, blames the 'rashness of Sempronius and Flaminius' for earlier disasters.

However, these sources must be treated carefully. Polybius and Livy follow an aristocratic tradition that was hostile to popular politicians like Flaminius and Varro; Livy reports gossip that Varro's father was a butcher. Polybius was a friend of Scipio Aemilianus, a grandson of Paullus, so he had reason to blame Varro rather than Paullus. Blaming individuals also protected the reputation of the Roman soldiers and the Roman state, which suited Livy's patriotic purpose under Augustus.

The defeats also owed much to Hannibal. Polybius uses Trasimene to teach that a general should study his opponent's mind, and he shows Hannibal predicting exactly how Flaminius would react. Hannibal chose ground carefully, hid troops at the Trebia and Trasimene, and at Cannae designed a formation that surrounded a much larger army. Polybius also explains that his soldiers were veterans trained in war from their youth, while the Roman armies were newly raised.

Even Fabius, in Livy's account, told the senate that the disasters of the last two years had come from the rashness and lack of skill of the commanders. Fabius had a motive, since he was defending his own cautious strategy against critics, but the events at the Trebia and Trasimene support him. Servilius, too, sent 4,000 cavalry under Centenius into Umbria without support, and Polybius says Maharbal destroyed them.

The Roman system was another cause. Consuls served for one year and wanted quick glory; at Cannae the consuls commanded on alternate days, so the aggressive one could commit the army. The soldiers themselves were eager to fight, and Paullus, the cautious consul, was defeated and killed just the same.

In conclusion, rashness made the defeats more likely, and the sources stress it, partly because of their bias against popular commanders. But Hannibal's brilliance, his veteran army and the weaknesses of the Roman system of command were at least as important, so rashness was one cause among several rather than the main one.

Explanation

A top answer weighs the rashness of Sempronius, Flaminius and Varro against Hannibal's skill and the Roman system, and evaluates the sources' aristocratic bias against popular commanders and Polybius' link to Paullus' family. Answers that list Roman mistakes without considering other causes or source reliability are capped.

Mark scheme
  1. 20 marks

    Levels of response (20 marks: AO3 10, AO1 5, AO2 5).
    Level 5 (17-20 marks): Detailed evaluation of the ancient sources in their historical context, with thorough analysis of their reliability and accuracy in terms of the context in which they were created, used to make developed, supported judgements and fully convincing conclusions (AO3). A range of detailed, accurate knowledge and a developed understanding (AO1). Thorough, convincing analysis with substantiated, developed judgements (AO2). A sustained, coherent and logically structured line of reasoning.
    Level 4 (13-16 marks): Detailed evaluation of the ancient sources in their context, with some analysis of their reliability and accuracy, used to make supported judgements and reasonable conclusions (AO3). Accurate knowledge and a developed understanding (AO1). A full analysis; judgements are substantiated but not consistently well developed (AO2). A clear, logically structured line of reasoning.
    Level 3 (9-12 marks): Analyses examples from the ancient sources, with a basic analysis of the reliability and accuracy of at least one source in terms of its context, used to make basic judgements and simple conclusions (AO3). Accurate knowledge and some understanding (AO1). Analysis and explanation; judgements may not be explicit (AO2). A mostly relevant line of reasoning with some structure.
    Level 2 (5-8 marks): Uses examples from the ancient sources, with a very basic attempt to consider a source's reliability or accuracy that may border on assertion; no source analysis is used to reach judgements (AO3). Basic knowledge and some understanding (AO1). A basic explanation (AO2). Some relevance; limited structure.
    Level 1 (1-4 marks): Basic use of the sources, with no attempt to consider their reliability or accuracy (AO3). Basic knowledge (AO1). Little or no explanation, close to assertion (AO2). Basic, unstructured communication.
    0 marks: No response or no response worthy of credit.

    Max 8 if the answer makes no use of the ancient sources (it never names, quotes or discusses any ancient writer, work, inscription, coin or other object, and knowing the events is not using the sources). Max 8 if the answer never considers how reliable or accurate any ancient source is. Max 12 if the answer considers only one side of the statement and never addresses the other (the issue of extent).
    No set answer is expected. It is possible to reach the highest mark either by agreeing or disagreeing with the statement (providing the issue of extent is addressed by refuting the counter-argument), or anywhere between. To access Level 3 and above, answers discuss the ancient sources; at lower levels they may only retell stories from the sources or name them. Candidates do not have to quote directly or give precise references.
    Grounds for agreeing include: Sempronius was provoked into fighting at the Trebia and sent his men out unfed through an icy river (Livy 21.54); Flaminius ignored his officers, refused to wait for Servilius and marched into the trap 'as if victory were certain' (Polybius 3.80-82); Varro gave the signal at Cannae without consulting Paullus (Livy 22.44-45); Servilius sent Centenius' cavalry ahead unsupported, and it was destroyed (Polybius 3.86); Paullus and Fabius both blamed the 'rashness' of earlier commanders (Livy 22.44, 22.25).
    Grounds for disagreeing include: Hannibal's genius: ambushes, choice of ground, the formation at Cannae (Livy 21.54, 22.46-47; Polybius 3.83-84); Hannibal's superior cavalry and veteran army (Polybius 3.89); the Roman system: one-year consuls, divided and alternating command, pressure from the people; Paullus, the cautious consul, was defeated too; the soldiers themselves were eager to fight (Livy 22.44); luck and conditions: the mist at Trasimene, the winter cold at the Trebia, the wind at Cannae.
    Likely sources to be included: Polybius, The Histories 3.80-3.86 (Flaminius, Trasimene, Centenius); Livy 21.54 (the Trebia); Livy 22.44-22.48 (Cannae); Livy 22.25-22.26 (Varro); Plutarch, Life of Fabius Maximus 5.
    The source analysis is likely to address: both Polybius and Livy follow an aristocratic tradition hostile to popular politicians (Flaminius, Varro), so they may exaggerate their rashness; Polybius was a friend of Scipio Aemilianus, grandson of Paullus, so he favours Paullus and blames Varro; blaming individual commanders protected the reputation of Roman soldiers and the Roman system; Livy's patriotic purpose fits this; Polybius uses Flaminius to teach that a general must study his opponent, which makes Hannibal's skill central too.
    Reductive comments ('Livy is Roman so biased', 'Polybius was not there') are basic analysis on their own.

Ready to try the rest? Every answer you write is marked against the mark scheme, so you can see exactly where the marks are.

Study Helper Hints first, answers after you try

Stuck on this one? Ask for a hint and I’ll point you in the right direction, without giving the answer away. Once you’ve checked your answer, I’ll show you how the marks are awarded.