'Rome's defeats in 218-216 BC were caused mainly by the rashness of its commanders.'
To what extent do you agree with this view?
You must use and analyse the ancient sources you have studied as well as supporting your answer with your own knowledge.
Model answer
Rash Roman commanders certainly contributed to the defeats of 218-216 BC, but Hannibal's skill and weaknesses in the Roman system were just as important, so I only partly agree.
The case for rashness is strong in the sources. At the Trebia, Livy shows Sempronius rushing out his whole army after the Numidian horsemen, with his men unfed and soaked by the icy river. Polybius describes Flaminius as over-confident and furious when Hannibal ravaged Etruria; he ignored his officers' advice to wait for his colleague and advanced 'as if victory were certain' into the ambush at Trasimene. Before Cannae, Livy shows Varro mocking Fabius' caution and giving the signal for battle without consulting Paullus. Even Paullus, in Livy, blames the 'rashness of Sempronius and Flaminius' for earlier disasters.
However, these sources must be treated carefully. Polybius and Livy follow an aristocratic tradition that was hostile to popular politicians like Flaminius and Varro; Livy reports gossip that Varro's father was a butcher. Polybius was a friend of Scipio Aemilianus, a grandson of Paullus, so he had reason to blame Varro rather than Paullus. Blaming individuals also protected the reputation of the Roman soldiers and the Roman state, which suited Livy's patriotic purpose under Augustus.
The defeats also owed much to Hannibal. Polybius uses Trasimene to teach that a general should study his opponent's mind, and he shows Hannibal predicting exactly how Flaminius would react. Hannibal chose ground carefully, hid troops at the Trebia and Trasimene, and at Cannae designed a formation that surrounded a much larger army. Polybius also explains that his soldiers were veterans trained in war from their youth, while the Roman armies were newly raised.
Even Fabius, in Livy's account, told the senate that the disasters of the last two years had come from the rashness and lack of skill of the commanders. Fabius had a motive, since he was defending his own cautious strategy against critics, but the events at the Trebia and Trasimene support him. Servilius, too, sent 4,000 cavalry under Centenius into Umbria without support, and Polybius says Maharbal destroyed them.
The Roman system was another cause. Consuls served for one year and wanted quick glory; at Cannae the consuls commanded on alternate days, so the aggressive one could commit the army. The soldiers themselves were eager to fight, and Paullus, the cautious consul, was defeated and killed just the same.
In conclusion, rashness made the defeats more likely, and the sources stress it, partly because of their bias against popular commanders. But Hannibal's brilliance, his veteran army and the weaknesses of the Roman system of command were at least as important, so rashness was one cause among several rather than the main one.