'Antony lost the Battle of Actium because of Cleopatra.'
How far do you agree with this view?
You must use and analyse the ancient sources you have studied as well as supporting your answer with your own knowledge.
Model answer
Cleopatra played an important part in Antony's defeat, but he lost mainly because Agrippa had already trapped him and because his own fleet was badly manned, so she was not the main cause.
The sources give strong grounds for blaming Cleopatra. Plutarch says Antony chose to fight at sea 'to please Cleopatra', although he was much stronger on land, and that her view prevailed over Canidius' advice to retreat and fight a land battle. He adds that she had already placed her ships where they could most easily escape. In the battle, her 60 ships hoisted their sails and broke through the centre of Antony's line, and Antony followed her. Velleius agrees that 'Cleopatra was the first to flee' and says Antony fled 'at her wish'. Her presence also cost Antony supporters: Plutarch says Plancus and Titius deserted after being abused by her, and Velleius says that Domitius, the only one of Antony's party who never addressed her as queen, went over to Octavian.
However, the military situation suggests that the battle was lost before Cleopatra fled. Velleius says Agrippa had stormed Leucas, captured Patrae, seized Corinth and twice defeated Antony's fleet, so Antony's supplies were cut off and his army trapped. Plutarch says his ships were so short of crews that his captains forced travellers and mule-drivers to row, and his giant ships were too slow to escape Octavian's light vessels. Kings and officers deserted daily. Antony himself made mistakes: Plutarch says delaying the war in 32 BC gave Octavian time to prepare. His order to carry sails suggests he planned to break out, not win, which makes Cleopatra's flight look like part of a plan rather than panic.
The reliability of the sources is central. Velleius and the Augustan poets had good reason to blame Cleopatra, because Octavian had presented the war as one against a foreign queen. Horace calls her a 'deadly monster' and Virgil shows Antony followed by his 'Egyptian wife', but these are celebrations, not histories. Velleius even contradicts himself, claiming victory was 'a certainty long before the battle' while blaming Cleopatra's flight. Plutarch is more detailed and used Augustus' own memoirs, but he moralises about Antony's passion; it is significant that he admits the battle was 'equally favourable to both sides' when she fled, which supports the idea that her flight mattered, but he also gives the military details that show Antony's weakness.
It is also worth remembering that none of these writers is known to have been present, and the only eyewitness account Plutarch mentions is Augustus' own, which had every reason to present the victory as complete.
Overall, Cleopatra's influence and flight helped to turn defeat into disaster, but Antony was already beaten by Agrippa's blockade, his undermanned fleet and his own decisions. I therefore largely disagree with the statement.
Explanation
High-level answers weigh Cleopatra's role (the choice of a sea battle, her flight, desertions she caused) against other causes (Agrippa's campaign, Antony's crews and ships, desertions, his own decisions) and analyse why Augustan sources blamed her. Answers that only retell the battle are capped at Level 2-3.