'The ancient sources only show Cleopatra in a negative way.'
How far do you agree with this view?
You must use and analyse the ancient sources you have studied as well as supporting your answer with your own knowledge.
Model answer
The literary sources are mostly negative about Cleopatra, but it is wrong to say that the sources 'only' show her negatively: even hostile writers admire her courage, Plutarch gives a balanced picture, and the archaeological sources are entirely positive.
The negative picture is strongest in the Augustan writers. Horace, writing in 30 BC, describes a mad queen 'drunk with sweet good fortune', plotting ruin for the Capitol with a 'polluted herd' of followers, and calls her a 'deadly monster'. Virgil shows Antony followed by his 'Egyptian wife', 'a shameful thing', and her monstrous gods, including 'barking Anubis'. Velleius says she led the flight at Actium and that Antony fled 'at her wish'. Cicero, a contemporary, writes 'I hate the queen' and complains of her arrogance. Plutarch calls Antony's love for her 'the crowning evil' of his life and shows her as manipulative and ruthless.
However, there are positive elements, even in hostile sources. Horace's poem ends by praising her: she 'did not fear the sword as women do' and was 'no humble woman'. Velleius says she died 'untouched by a woman's fear'. Plutarch admires her 'irresistible' charm, her voice and her many languages, records her wit, reports Canidius' view that she 'governed so large a kingdom by herself', and describes her love for Antony and her dignified death. Suetonius shows Caesar honouring her, and Dio admits she held real power.
The archaeological sources are positive by design. The Dendera relief shows her as an Egyptian queen with the symbols of Isis and Hathor behind Caesarion as pharaoh; her coins show her as a Greek queen wearing the diadem, and the Cyprus coin as a divine mother; the denarius calls her 'queen of kings and of her sons who are kings'.
The reasons for these patterns are clear. Augustan writers needed Cleopatra as the foreign enemy who made Octavian's civil war a foreign war; even their praise of her courage makes his victory greater. Cicero's hostility is personal and political. Plutarch, a Greek writing over a century later, is more balanced but moralises about Antony's passion and uses hostile sources. The archaeological sources are her own propaganda, so they show how she wanted to be seen. Most literary sources were written by Roman men about a foreign queen, which shapes their view. We have no account written by Cleopatra herself or by an Egyptian or Alexandrian who supported her, so the balance of the surviving evidence is itself a result of her defeat.
Overall, I disagree with the statement. The literary sources are mainly negative, but they include real admiration, and her own monuments and coins give a strongly positive picture.
Explanation
High-level answers test the word 'only' against a range of literary and archaeological sources, explain why most literary sources are hostile (Augustan propaganda, Roman attitudes, personal bias) and note the positive elements even in hostile writers. Lists of negative quotations without analysis stay at Level 2-3.