Passage A
Livy describes the state of Rome in 495 BC.
'A war with the Volsci was threatening, and the city was burning with hatred between the patricians and the plebeians, above all because of the men bound for debt. They complained that while they fought abroad for liberty and empire, at home they were captured and oppressed by their fellow citizens... An old man, showing all the marks of his sufferings, rushed into the Forum... People recognised him as a former centurion, and he showed the scars on his chest from honourable battles... He said that while he was serving in the Sabine war, enemy raids had ruined his crops, his farmhouse had been burned, everything plundered and his cattle driven off; then a tax had been demanded at a bad time for him, and he had fallen into debt. The debt, swollen by interest, had stripped him first of his father's and grandfather's farm, then of his other property. His creditor had taken him away, not into slavery, but into a prison and a place of punishment.'
Livy, The History of Rome 2.23.1-6 (adapted)
Using details from Passage A and your own knowledge, what can we learn about the problems facing the plebeians in the first years of the Republic?
Model answer
The passage shows that the plebeians' biggest problem was debt. Livy says the city was 'burning with hatred between the patricians and the plebeians... above all because of the men bound for debt', which refers to nexum, where a borrower pledged his own body as security. The plebeians also felt their military service was not rewarded: 'while they fought abroad for liberty and empire, at home they were captured and oppressed'. This was a real grievance because Rome was at war almost every year after 509 BC, against the Tarquins, Porsena, the Latins and now 'the Volsci'.
The old centurion's story shows how war led to debt. He was 'a former centurion' and had 'scars on his chest from honourable battles', so even loyal and brave soldiers were ruined. While he served, 'enemy raids had ruined his crops, his farmhouse had been burned... cattle driven off', and 'a tax had been demanded at a bad time', so he had to borrow. 'The debt, swollen by interest' cost him 'his father's and grandfather's farm', showing that families were losing their ancestral land. Finally he was taken 'into a prison and a place of punishment', and Livy adds that he showed fresh marks of beating on his back, so debtors lost their freedom and could be mistreated.
From my own knowledge, the plebeians had no protection: the consuls and Senate were patricians, and in 495 Appius Claudius judged debt cases as harshly as possible. The promises of Servilius and later of the dictator Manius Valerius were broken, which led to the First Secession in 494. The old man may be a dramatic example created to stand for many, but the problems he shows (war, debt and harsh creditors) fit the rest of Livy's account.
Explanation
Top answers use details from across the passage (the hatred, the soldiers' complaint, the war damage, the tax, interest, loss of the farm and imprisonment) and explain what each shows, adding own knowledge such as nexum, Appius Claudius' judgements and the broken promises. Answers that retell the old man's story without explaining the problems stay in Level 2 or 3.