Question 1
2 marksGive two ways in which Hannibal used the weather or the landscape to help him win battles in 218-216 BC.
Model answer
At Lake Trasimene he hid his army on the hills around a narrow valley and attacked in the morning mist. At Cannae he chose flat open ground where his cavalry could be used, and the wind blew dust into the Romans' faces.
Explanation
Hannibal chose his battlefields carefully: the overgrown stream bed and icy river at the Trebia, the hills, lake and mist at Trasimene, and the open plain and dusty wind at Cannae. A common error is to give general answers such as 'he used the land' without saying how.
Mark scheme
-
2 marks
Any two of: at the Trebia he hid troops (Mago's force) in a stream bed overgrown with bushes; at the Trebia he drew the Romans across an icy river in winter, so they were cold, wet and hungry; at Trasimene he hid his army on the hills around a narrow valley beside the lake; at Trasimene the morning mist hid his troops; at Cannae he fought on flat, open ground suited to his cavalry; at Cannae the wind (the Volturnus) blew dust into the Romans' faces; at Cannae the river protected one flank / hemmed in the Roman cavalry
1 mark for each different correct answer, max 2. Allow recognisable spellings. The two answers may come from the same battle if they are different features. Credit any other historically valid answer.
Livy (22.46) and Polybius (3.114) both say the sun did not shine in the face of either army at Cannae, so 'the sun in the Romans' eyes' does not score on its own; an answer that joins it to a valid feature (for example the wind blowing dust into the Romans' faces) is credited for that feature.