Level:
Correct: 0
Incorrect: 0
Marks: 0/0
Exam Practice
Course:
Topics:
OCR GCSE Ancient History (Rome and its neighbours) Smart practice A mixed round aimed at your weak spots
Unit 1
The foundations of Rome: from kingship to republic, 753-440 BC (longer period study)
Unit 2
Hannibal and the Second Punic War, 218-201 BC (depth study)
Unit 3
Cleopatra: Rome and Egypt, 69-30 BC (depth study)
Unit 4
Britannia: from conquest to province, AD 43-c.84 (depth study)
Avg
score:
–
Topics
done:
0/45

The sources for the Second Punic War

Practise 12 exam-style questions on The sources for the Second Punic War for OCR GCSE Ancient History (Rome and its neighbours). Write your answer as you would in the exam and get it marked in seconds against the mark scheme, point by point, with the Study Helper on hand if you get stuck.

  • 12 questions
  • 1–20 marks each
  • Instant marking
  • No sign-up needed
12 questions, marked as you go

Sample questions with model answers

Here are 4 of the questions in this topic, each with a model answer, an explanation of why it earns the marks and the mark scheme an examiner would use.

Question 1

1 mark

Name one of the Greek writers who accompanied Hannibal on his campaigns and wrote an account of the war.

Model answer

Sosylus of Sparta, who taught Hannibal Greek.

Explanation

Silenus and Sosylus travelled with Hannibal and wrote pro-Carthaginian accounts that are now lost. Livy cites Silenus (for example on the booty at New Carthage), and Polybius dismisses Sosylus' work as barber's-shop gossip, so they reached later historians only indirectly.

Mark scheme
  1. 1 mark

    Silenus (of Caleacte) / Sosylus (of Sparta)

    1 mark. Allow recognisable spellings. Do not credit Polybius (born after the war), Plutarch, Chaereas (criticised by Polybius, but not known to have been with Hannibal) or Fabius Pictor.

Question 2

5 marks

Source B

The dedication for Quintus Fabius Maximus (CIL 11.1828). This inscription was found at Arretium (modern Arezzo) in Etruria and is now in Florence. It was probably made in the time of Augustus (late first century BC or early first century AD), and its text is thought to copy the inscription that stood under Fabius' statue in the Forum of Augustus in Rome, among the statues of great Romans of the past. The first line is lost. In translation it reads:

'[Quintus Fabius] Maximus, son of Quintus; twice dictator, five times consul, censor, twice interrex, curule aedile, twice quaestor, twice military tribune, pontifex, augur. In his first consulship he conquered the Ligurians and celebrated a triumph over them. In his third and fourth consulships he held in check Hannibal, who was fierce after many victories, by following close behind him. As dictator he came to the help of the master of horse Minucius, whose power the people had made equal to the dictator's, and of his beaten army, and for this he was called "father" by Minucius' army. In his fifth consulship he captured Tarentum and celebrated a triumph. He was thought the most cautious general of his time and the most skilled in warfare. He was chosen leader of the senate at two censuses.'

What can we learn from Source B about Fabius Maximus' career?

Model answer

Source B shows that Fabius had an outstanding career. He held the highest offices many times, 'twice dictator, five times consul', and was also 'pontifex' and 'augur', so he was an important religious figure, which fits his use of religion in 217 BC. He was already a successful general, conquering the Ligurians and celebrating a 'triumph' in his first consulship. In the war against Hannibal, his method was to hold Hannibal 'in check' by 'following close behind him' rather than fighting, which is the Fabian strategy. The inscription also hints at political conflict, since the people had made Minucius' power 'equal to the dictator's', but Fabius rescued Minucius' 'beaten army' and was called 'father'. Later he 'captured Tarentum', so he could attack too. Finally, he was remembered as 'the most cautious general of his time' and was 'leader of the senate', Rome's most respected senator.

Explanation

High-level answers explain what each part of the inscription shows: his offices and priesthoods, the strategy of shadowing Hannibal, the rescue of Minucius, the capture of Tarentum and his reputation. Simply copying the list of offices without saying what it shows earns Level 1.

Mark scheme
  1. 5 marks

    Levels of response (5 marks, AO3).
    Level 3 (4-5 marks): Response uses a range of fully appropriate details from the passage, which are analysed to draw out relevant characteristics and features and give a detailed and sophisticated evaluation of what we can learn from the source about the specified issue in the question.
    Level 2 (2-3 marks): Response uses some appropriate details from the passage, which are analysed to draw out some of the characteristics and features and evaluate what we can learn from the source about the specified issue in the question.
    Level 1 (1 mark): Response uses few details from the passage and makes a very basic attempt to draw out any of the characteristics and features in relation to the question.
    0 marks: No response or no response worthy of credit.

    Max 1 if the answer makes no use of the source (own knowledge alone does not answer this question).
    Details must be explained, not just copied: credit what each detail tells us about the issue. A Level 3 answer explains a range of details from across the source; a Level 1 answer only picks out or copies a detail or two. Own knowledge may be used to explain a detail but is not required.
    Candidates are likely to pick out and explain: 'twice dictator, five times consul, censor ...': a long and exceptionally distinguished career in the highest offices; 'pontifex, augur': he held major priesthoods, which fits his use of religion as dictator in 217 BC; 'In his first consulship he conquered the Ligurians and celebrated a triumph': he was already a successful general before the war; 'In his third and fourth consulships he held in check Hannibal ... by following close behind him': the Fabian strategy of shadowing Hannibal rather than fighting him, continued after Cannae; 'Hannibal, who was fierce after many victories': the strategy is presented as the answer to a dangerous enemy; 'whose power the people had made equal to the dictator's': political conflict with the people and Minucius in 217 BC; 'came to the help of ... Minucius ... called "father" by Minucius' army': he rescued a rash colleague and won gratitude; 'captured Tarentum and celebrated a triumph': he could also win offensive victories late in the war (209 BC); 'the most cautious general of his time and the most skilled in warfare': his reputation was for caution and expertise; 'leader of the senate at two censuses': he was Rome's leading senator.
    Answers may also comment on what the source leaves out (his unpopularity, his opposition to Scipio), but this is not required for this question.

Question 3

5 marks

Passage B

Plutarch describes how Minucius, master of horse to the dictator Fabius, criticised him in 217 BC.

'This made Minucius all the more arrogant and bold. He mocked the camps on the heights, saying that the dictator was always giving them fine seats in the theatre from which to watch Italy being laid waste with fire and sword. He would ask Fabius' friends whether Fabius was taking the army up to heaven, having given up hope on earth, or was wrapping himself in clouds and mist to escape the enemy. When his friends told Fabius this and advised him to wipe out the disgrace by risking a battle, he replied, 'In that case I would be a greater coward than I am now said to be, if I gave up my settled plans out of fear of jokes and insults. There is nothing shameful in fearing for one's country; but to be frightened out of one's course by men's opinions and slanders is the mark of a man unworthy of such high office, who makes himself the slave of the fools he ought to command.''

Plutarch, Life of Fabius Maximus 5.5-6 (adapted)

Using details from Passage B, how accurate do you think Plutarch's account of Minucius' criticism and Fabius' reply is?

Model answer

Plutarch's account is probably accurate about the criticism Fabius faced, but the words themselves are literary. Plutarch wrote about three hundred years later and relied on earlier writers. However, Minucius' mockery is supported by Livy, who also has him complain that the army watches the allies' lands burn from the hills and wanders through 'clouds' and mountains, so jokes like 'fine seats in the theatre' and 'clouds and mist' probably come from an older tradition. Other sources also confirm that Fabius was unpopular and that Minucius was later given equal power. Fabius' reply, though, is in direct speech and sounds like a moral lesson: 'There is nothing shameful in fearing for one's country.' Plutarch wrote biography to show character, so he probably shaped this speech to display Fabius' steadfastness. Overall, the situation is reliable, but the exact words and the sharp contrast between the arrogant Minucius and wise Fabius reflect Plutarch's purpose.

Explanation

Strong answers combine Plutarch's context and purpose (a later biographer teaching moral lessons) with the evidence of other sources (Livy's similar speech for Minucius, the grant of equal power) to judge particular details. Simply saying 'Plutarch lived much later' earns Level 1.

Mark scheme
  1. 5 marks

    Levels of response (5 marks, AO3).
    Level 3 (4-5 marks): Response analyses the source by using relevant detail from the source content or historical context to give a more detailed evaluation of the source within its historical context. It draws a thorough and convincing conclusion about its accuracy or reliability based on how the context in which it was created impacts on how it portrays issues or events.
    Level 2 (2-3 marks): Response analyses the source by using relevant detail from the source content or historical context to give a basic evaluation of the source within its historical context. It draws a basic conclusion about its accuracy or reliability based on how the context in which it was created impacts on how it portrays issues or events.
    Level 1 (1 mark): Response analyses the source in a basic way by selecting relevant detail from the source content or historical context.
    0 marks: No response or no response worthy of credit.

    Max 1 if the answer reaches no conclusion at all about how accurate or reliable the passage is.
    Full marks need the evaluation to be related to the particular events in the passage, not only general comments about the author. A conclusion that the passage is accurate, inaccurate or partly accurate can all reach Level 3 if it is supported. Treat bare assertions such as 'he was not there' or 'he was biased' with care: on their own they are Level 1.
    Candidates might comment on: Plutarch (about AD 46-120) wrote about three hundred years later, relying on earlier writers rather than witnesses; he wrote biography (the Parallel Lives) to show character and teach moral lessons; Fabius' reply ('There is nothing shameful in fearing for one's country ...') expresses the virtue of steadfastness that Plutarch wants to illustrate; the speech is in direct speech and is probably Plutarch's own composition, or polished from an earlier version; Minucius' mockery has a parallel in Livy (22.14), where Minucius complains that the army is watching the allies' lands burn from the hills and marching through woods and clouds, so the criticism belongs to an older tradition; the general situation is confirmed: Fabius' strategy was unpopular and Minucius was later given equal power (Livy 22.25-26; Polybius 3.90; Source B, the dedication for Fabius); the vivid jokes (theatre seats, going up to heaven, clouds and mist) are memorable and may have been sharpened in retelling; Plutarch presents Minucius as arrogant and Fabius as wise, which suits his purpose and the later reputation of Fabius as Rome's saviour.

Question 4

20 marks

'The ancient sources present Hannibal more as a villain than as a hero.'

How far do you agree with this view?

You must use and analyse the ancient sources you have studied as well as supporting your answer with your own knowledge.

Model answer

The sources do contain hostile comments on Hannibal, especially in Livy, but overall they present him as a great, even heroic enemy, so I disagree with the statement.

There is certainly a hostile strand. Fabius Pictor, reported by Polybius, blamed the war on the ambition of the Barcid family. Polybius himself says Hannibal used Saguntum as a pretext and was driven by 'violent anger'. Livy repeatedly uses the stereotype of 'Punic' treachery: in the Alps he says Hannibal was nearly destroyed by his own methods of deceit and ambush, and at Cannae he describes Numidians pretending to desert and then attacking from behind. Polybius also records that on his march to the Adriatic Hannibal ordered adults to be killed out of hatred for Rome.

These hostile elements come from a Roman viewpoint. No Carthaginian account survives; Fabius Pictor was a Roman senator and Livy a patriotic Roman writing under Augustus, for whom Carthaginian deceit explained Roman defeats. Polybius does not mention the false deserters at Cannae, which suggests Livy's story is a Roman addition.

On the other hand, the sources often admire Hannibal. Polybius, a soldier who crossed the Alps himself, praises his practical planning and shows him cheering his exhausted men with the view of Italy and rebuilding the path through the snow. He uses Hannibal's study of Flaminius' character to teach what a good general should do. Plutarch says that only Hannibal understood Fabius' cleverness. Even Livy, at Zama, says that Scipio and all experts agreed that Hannibal had arranged his army with outstanding skill, and in Hannibal's speech to Scipio he gives him dignity and wisdom about the changes of fortune. Livy also describes him searching for Flaminius' body to give it honourable burial. After Zama, Polybius shows him as a patriot, urging the Carthaginian senate to accept peace for the city's sake.

Livy's speeches for Hannibal also deserve comment. In his meeting with Scipio before Zama, Livy gives Hannibal a thoughtful speech about the uncertainty of fortune and the value of peace. The speech is Livy's own composition, but by choosing to give Hannibal such words he presents him as wise in defeat, not as a monster. Similarly, Hannibal's angry speech on his recall shows a frustrated patriot betrayed by his own senate rather than a villain.

This praise also had a purpose. A great enemy made Rome's victory greater, so Roman and pro-Roman writers had reason to present Hannibal as heroic in ability, while condemning his 'Punic' character. Polybius wanted to teach generalship and Livy to show how Rome survived its greatest test.

In conclusion, the sources mix admiration for Hannibal's genius with criticism of his character, but the admiration is stronger. He appears as a brilliant and dangerous enemy rather than simply a villain, partly because his greatness made Rome's victory more glorious.

Explanation

A top answer uses several set sources on both sides (Livy's 'Punic' stereotypes and praise at Zama, Polybius' admiration and criticism, Plutarch) and explains why each writer portrays Hannibal as he does, including the point that a great enemy made Rome's victory greater.

Mark scheme
  1. 20 marks

    Levels of response (20 marks: AO3 10, AO1 5, AO2 5).
    Level 5 (17-20 marks): Detailed evaluation of the ancient sources in their historical context, with thorough analysis of their reliability and accuracy in terms of the context in which they were created, used to make developed, supported judgements and fully convincing conclusions (AO3). A range of detailed, accurate knowledge and a developed understanding (AO1). Thorough, convincing analysis with substantiated, developed judgements (AO2). A sustained, coherent and logically structured line of reasoning.
    Level 4 (13-16 marks): Detailed evaluation of the ancient sources in their context, with some analysis of their reliability and accuracy, used to make supported judgements and reasonable conclusions (AO3). Accurate knowledge and a developed understanding (AO1). A full analysis; judgements are substantiated but not consistently well developed (AO2). A clear, logically structured line of reasoning.
    Level 3 (9-12 marks): Analyses examples from the ancient sources, with a basic analysis of the reliability and accuracy of at least one source in terms of its context, used to make basic judgements and simple conclusions (AO3). Accurate knowledge and some understanding (AO1). Analysis and explanation; judgements may not be explicit (AO2). A mostly relevant line of reasoning with some structure.
    Level 2 (5-8 marks): Uses examples from the ancient sources, with a very basic attempt to consider a source's reliability or accuracy that may border on assertion; no source analysis is used to reach judgements (AO3). Basic knowledge and some understanding (AO1). A basic explanation (AO2). Some relevance; limited structure.
    Level 1 (1-4 marks): Basic use of the sources, with no attempt to consider their reliability or accuracy (AO3). Basic knowledge (AO1). Little or no explanation, close to assertion (AO2). Basic, unstructured communication.
    0 marks: No response or no response worthy of credit.

    Max 8 if the answer makes no use of the ancient sources (it never names, quotes or discusses any ancient writer, work, inscription, coin or other object, and knowing the events is not using the sources). Max 8 if the answer never considers how reliable or accurate any ancient source is. Max 12 if the answer considers only one side of the statement and never addresses the other (the issue of extent).
    No set answer is expected. It is possible to reach the highest mark either by agreeing or disagreeing with the statement (providing the issue of extent is addressed by refuting the counter-argument), or anywhere between. To access Level 3 and above, answers discuss the ancient sources; at lower levels they may only retell stories from the sources or name them. Candidates do not have to quote directly or give precise references.
    Grounds for agreeing include: Livy stresses 'Punic' deceit: the false deserters at Cannae (22.48); in the Alps Hannibal nearly destroyed by his own methods of deceit and ambush (21.34); Livy's speech for Scipio at Zama attacks Carthaginian faithlessness (30.31); Hannibal is called the cause of the war (30.29); Polybius says Hannibal used Saguntum as a pretext and was ruled by violent anger (3.15); Fabius Pictor (in Polybius 3.8) blames the war on Barcid ambition; Hannibal's treatment of Roman prisoners and the killing of adults on his march (Polybius 3.85-86); Livy 26.11 shows him plundering the temple at Feronia.
    Grounds for disagreeing include: Polybius admires Hannibal's rational planning (3.48 on the Alps; 3.81 on understanding Flaminius) and his leadership in the Alps (3.54-55); Livy praises his dispositions at Zama, saying Scipio and all experts agreed (30.35); Plutarch says only Hannibal understood Fabius' cleverness (Fabius 5); Livy shows Hannibal's dignity and wisdom in his speech to Scipio (30.30) and his care for the dead after Trasimene (22.7); Polybius shows Hannibal as a patriot urging peace for Carthage's sake (15.19); the sources make him a worthy, even heroic enemy, which magnifies Rome's victory.
    Likely sources to be included: Livy 21.32-21.35; 22.7; 22.48; 30.29-30.35; Polybius, The Histories 3.8; 3.15; 3.54-3.55; 3.80-3.85; 15.19; Plutarch, Life of Fabius Maximus 5.
    The source analysis is likely to address: the sources are Roman or pro-Roman (Fabius Pictor, Livy) or Greek friends of Rome (Polybius); no Carthaginian account survives, though Silenus and Sosylus were used indirectly; Livy's moral purpose and the Roman stereotype of 'Punic faith' shape his negative comments; Polybius' interest in teaching generalship leads him to admire Hannibal's methods; making Hannibal a great enemy made Rome's victory greater, so even praise may serve Roman purposes.
    Reductive comments ('Livy is Roman so biased', 'Polybius was not there') are basic analysis on their own.

Ready to try the rest? Every answer you write is marked against the mark scheme, so you can see exactly where the marks are.

Study Helper Hints first, answers after you try

Stuck on this one? Ask for a hint and I’ll point you in the right direction, without giving the answer away. Once you’ve checked your answer, I’ll show you how the marks are awarded.