'The ancient sources present Hannibal more as a villain than as a hero.'
How far do you agree with this view?
You must use and analyse the ancient sources you have studied as well as supporting your answer with your own knowledge.
Model answer
The sources do contain hostile comments on Hannibal, especially in Livy, but overall they present him as a great, even heroic enemy, so I disagree with the statement.
There is certainly a hostile strand. Fabius Pictor, reported by Polybius, blamed the war on the ambition of the Barcid family. Polybius himself says Hannibal used Saguntum as a pretext and was driven by 'violent anger'. Livy repeatedly uses the stereotype of 'Punic' treachery: in the Alps he says Hannibal was nearly destroyed by his own methods of deceit and ambush, and at Cannae he describes Numidians pretending to desert and then attacking from behind. Polybius also records that on his march to the Adriatic Hannibal ordered adults to be killed out of hatred for Rome.
These hostile elements come from a Roman viewpoint. No Carthaginian account survives; Fabius Pictor was a Roman senator and Livy a patriotic Roman writing under Augustus, for whom Carthaginian deceit explained Roman defeats. Polybius does not mention the false deserters at Cannae, which suggests Livy's story is a Roman addition.
On the other hand, the sources often admire Hannibal. Polybius, a soldier who crossed the Alps himself, praises his practical planning and shows him cheering his exhausted men with the view of Italy and rebuilding the path through the snow. He uses Hannibal's study of Flaminius' character to teach what a good general should do. Plutarch says that only Hannibal understood Fabius' cleverness. Even Livy, at Zama, says that Scipio and all experts agreed that Hannibal had arranged his army with outstanding skill, and in Hannibal's speech to Scipio he gives him dignity and wisdom about the changes of fortune. Livy also describes him searching for Flaminius' body to give it honourable burial. After Zama, Polybius shows him as a patriot, urging the Carthaginian senate to accept peace for the city's sake.
Livy's speeches for Hannibal also deserve comment. In his meeting with Scipio before Zama, Livy gives Hannibal a thoughtful speech about the uncertainty of fortune and the value of peace. The speech is Livy's own composition, but by choosing to give Hannibal such words he presents him as wise in defeat, not as a monster. Similarly, Hannibal's angry speech on his recall shows a frustrated patriot betrayed by his own senate rather than a villain.
This praise also had a purpose. A great enemy made Rome's victory greater, so Roman and pro-Roman writers had reason to present Hannibal as heroic in ability, while condemning his 'Punic' character. Polybius wanted to teach generalship and Livy to show how Rome survived its greatest test.
In conclusion, the sources mix admiration for Hannibal's genius with criticism of his character, but the admiration is stronger. He appears as a brilliant and dangerous enemy rather than simply a villain, partly because his greatness made Rome's victory more glorious.