Passage D
Tacitus describes the governors of Britain in the late 50s AD.
'In Britain, the governor Aulus Didius had, as I have said, only held on to what had been won, and his successor Veranius, after ravaging the Silures in some minor raids, was prevented by death from carrying the war further. In his lifetime he had a great reputation for strictness, but the last words of his will showed his ambition: after much flattery of Nero, he added that he would have conquered the province for him if he had lived for the next two years. Then Suetonius Paulinus held Britain. In military skill and in popular reputation, which allows no one to be without a rival, he competed with Corbulo, and he wanted to equal the glory of the recovery of Armenia by crushing Rome's enemies. So he prepared to attack the island of Mona, which had a strong population and was a refuge for fugitives.'
Tacitus, Annals 14.29 (adapted)
Using details from Passage D, how accurate do you think Tacitus' account of the governors Veranius and Suetonius Paulinus is?
Model answer
Tacitus' account is accurate in its facts but coloured by his opinions. As a senator writing about sixty years later he could read senate records, and his father-in-law Agricola served under Paulinus, so he had good information. The facts agree with his Agricola: Didius 'only held on to what had been won', and Veranius died after a short governorship, which the Agricola also says. Mona as 'a refuge for fugitives' also fits Dio and the Agricola. However, Tacitus' judgements are his own. His sneer that Veranius' will 'showed his ambition' with 'much flattery of Nero' reflects his dislike of flatterers, and Paulinus' wish to rival Corbulo and 'equal the glory of the recovery of Armenia' is his interpretation of motives he could not know. So the events are reliable, but the character judgements are less so.
Explanation
Top answers separate facts that can be cross-checked (Didius' caution, Veranius' death, Mona) from Tacitus' interpretations of motive and character, and link these to his context as a senator who disliked flattery and wrote with hindsight.